The Book Mine Set

Book discussion blog with a Canadian bias.

Saturday, January 30, 2010

Reader's Diary #572- Alan Moore (Writer), Dave Gibbons (Illustrator): Watchmen

For years now I've been using a blurb from the back of Irving Welsh's Trainspotting as the best example of oversell:

"The best book ever written by man or woman...deserves to sell more copies than the Bible." - Rebel, Inc.

The only way such a blurb as this can possibly work is for potential readers to pick up the book in defiance, as in, "We'll see about that!"

I'd bought my copy of Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons' Watchmen online, so I'd not seen the blurbs ahead of time. However, as many of us do when we get a brand new book, I went to the back cover right away. There at the top is a quote from TIME Magazine from an article declaring Watchmen to be one of the best English-language novels of all time. I'd heard that before and admit that Time's endorsement did influence my decision to buy it. However, further down the blurbs there's a quote from Damon Lindelof, co-creator of Lost:

"The greatest piece of popular fiction ever produced."

Lindelof doesn't steal the hyperbole crown from Rebel, Inc, but I did find myself once again declaring, "Oh yeah? We'll see about that!"

And surprise, surprise, it's not in fact the greatest piece of popular fiction ever produced. How do I know? For starters it's not even the greatest graphic novel ever written. (And you can blame Lindelof for my use of such an unnecessary criticism.)

As I was struggling through Watchmen, I found myself defending my new love of graphic novels to a friend. This friend wasn't against graphic novels, just the opposite, but somehow he had gotten the impression that I turned up my nose at them. "Au contraire," I said (which turns out not to be the phrase you use to prove you are not a snob), and merely suggested that I was late to the game. "That could be your issue with Watchmen," he decided, "if you weren't into superhero comics as a kid, you probably wouldn't appreciate it as much."

Finally some honesty here! This isn't a stand alone novel, this needs context, this needs more than a passing familiarity with Superman, Batman and all the other costumed heroes in order to be experienced fully. I found myself thinking of Nirvana's Nevermind album. I should note up front that I absolutely loved that album. I had it twice on cassette, when the 2nd wore out, I got it on CD, and now it's on my iPod. I still listen to it on occasion. However, and believe it or not, I never bought into their hype or the hype of alternative music that surrounded them. Wait one sec, Nirvana still played rock music did they not? Now polka, that's the real alternative. With the exception of killing hair metal, Nirvana didn't really change the music scene. What was the most popular song in the world just five years after Nevermind? "Wannabe" by the Spice Girls. As it turned out, people still wanted to have fun. But, in the wake of Nirvana you had to choose: good music or fun.

Hi there, I just got back from my tangent. Somewhere along the way I meant to show how Watchmen was like Nevermind, but after such a long trip, I'm too lazy to connect my own dots right now.

My problems with Watchmen:
1. Convoluted plot
2. Artistry- Even with my limited experience with superhero comics, I still thought the characters were standard hero fare: lazy, rushed sketch quality, boring angles, and a horrible colourization that made me think of 1970s wallpaper
3. Middle aged crisis- I get it, comic book fans had grown up. But good Lord, did they all need shrinks and Prozac? The psychological elements were simultaneously heavy handed and surface level. Too much, too little depth. A 200m wading pool of disillusionment. Have you had enough yet?

Something nice, something nice... Oh, I've got one! The comic within the comic: Tales of the Black Freighter. In the alternate universe of Moore's, people are not interested in superhero comics, but are instead into pirate stories. One of these comics is being read by a boy in New York City and while it doesn't enter into the main plot at all, it does has some interesting parallels. Plus, I thought it was a nice reprieve from a novel I didn't really care for.

So to Lindelof, TIME writers, and other fans: I'm sorry I didn't like your recommendation. Maybe you just want to enjoy it on your own time. I liked Nirvana, but let's face it, they weren't all that.

Labels: , , , ,

Blogger Teddy Rose said...

"The best book ever written by man or woman...deserves to sell more copies than the Bible." - Rebel, Inc. That quote me ROTFLMAO (rolling on the floor laughing my a$$ off).

Whenever I see a quote like that, I get suspicious. Are they just saying that to get me to buy it> etc.

I'll skip this book.

Tuesday, 02 February, 2010  
Blogger John Mutford said...

Teddy: Actually, that blurb was for Trainspotting and despite it, it was still a pretty good book. I did, however, read it aloud to understand the Scottish dialogue.

Tuesday, 02 February, 2010  
Blogger Teddy Rose said...

Actually John, I don't think either book would be my cuppa java.

Wednesday, 03 February, 2010  

Thursday, January 28, 2010

Niche market?


If you're Superman (or a pirate or a French maid), you have a few bucks in your pocket, and you find yourself in Hay River this weekend, why not help yourself to some condiments?

Labels: ,

Blogger kylewith said...

Arrrr I just might do that. haha

Thursday, 28 January, 2010  
Blogger Jason said...

LOL. What about all the grammar errors?!

Thursday, 28 January, 2010  
Blogger John Mutford said...

Kyle: Pay in dubloons.

Jason: Costumed people no worry about grammar. Too busy bringing food from different store

Thursday, 28 January, 2010  
Blogger Barbara Bruederlin said...

Let me getting my paying costume back from the cleaners first. I want to be respon
sible.

Friday, 29 January, 2010  
Blogger Allison said...

Ha! Barb commented on what I was going to say about "responsible" being split like that. One of my biggest pet peeves.

On a completely unrelated note - was it hear that I read about All My Friends Are Superheroes? I think it was...I picked it up last week and enjoyed it thoroughly.

Friday, 29 January, 2010  
Blogger John Mutford said...

Barbara: But how will you pay the cleaners without your paying costume on?

Allison: It was over at Remi's. But that makes two, two recommendations, ah-ah-ah.

Friday, 29 January, 2010  
Blogger Teddy Rose said...

i lik bring other food from nother store and using condoms there.

Tuesday, 02 February, 2010  

Wednesday, January 27, 2010

The Great Wednesday Compare #5- Ann-Marie MacDonald VERSUS Joseph Boyden



The final winner of last week's Great Wednesday Compare (Ann-Marie MacDonald Vs Carson McCullers), with a final score of 5-3, was Ann-Marie MacDonald!

This week we bid farewell to Carson McCullers. If you happened to catch my ranking of favourite novels read last year, you might remember that my number one was McCullers' The Heart is a Lonely Hunter. I still don't like the title, but man, what a fine book. As B.Kienapple said in the comments last week, it was "chillingly excellent." Now I need to read something else by her.

In any case, we move on.

Remember, vote simply by adding your comment below, base it on whatever merit you choose, voting does not end until Tuesday at 11:59 p.m. (Feb 2, 2010), and if you want your book to get more votes, feel free to promote them here or on your blog!

Who is better?

Labels: , ,

Blogger Kate said...

Oh no - now I'm torn! Two authors whose books I have read and loved. Can I cast 2 votes this week? OK, let's approach this logically. Of the books by these authors that I have read (Fall on your Knees, The Way the Crow Flies, and Goodnight Desdemona, Good Morning Juliet by Ann-Marie MacDonald; and Three Day Road and Through Black Spruce by Joseph Boyden), my favourite would have to be Fall on Your Knees. So my vote this week is staying with:

Ann-Marie MacDonald.

Tough call this week, and I'll be happy no matter who wins!

Wednesday, 27 January, 2010  
Blogger Scrat said...

Oh John -- you are TRULY EVIL! How can you torture us so???? Like Kate, I too have read and loved all the novels she has enumerated. My favourite though is Through Black Spruce by Joseph Boyen, followed closely by The Way the Crow Flies. Hence, my vote this week will have to go to Joseph Boyden...with sincere apologies extended to Ann-Marie Macdonald. (Subliminal message --Blame John, Blame John!)

Wednesday, 27 January, 2010  
Blogger Dale said...

No accusations of torture but you may want to torture me - I've never read Boyden. I have read and loved Ann-Marie so she gets my vote.

Wednesday, 27 January, 2010  
Blogger Barbara Bruederlin said...

I have never read Joseph Boyden's books, but wasn't he the author you were locking lips with last year? Yeah, he gets my vote for that.

Thursday, 28 January, 2010  
Blogger Melwyk said...

Oh, tough decision to make. I think I'll go with Joseph Boyden though, as he got some of my nonreading friends to actually read, with his Three Day Road. So my vote goes to him this week.

Sunday, 31 January, 2010  
Blogger Kerri said...

Having fallen in love with Through Black Spruce my vote will be for Boyden.

Monday, 01 February, 2010  
Blogger Teddy Rose said...

John, you realize we are comparing apples to oranges here. Both authors are great but do have different styles. It's almost a toss up for me. So sorry Ann-Marie but this week I have to go with Joseph Boyden.

Tuesday, 02 February, 2010  
Blogger John Mutford said...

Teddy: Actually, we did that before and apples won.

Tuesday, 02 February, 2010  
Blogger Wanda said...

Love her plays; love her novels!
My vote once again goes to Ann-Marie MacDonald.

Tuesday, 02 February, 2010  
Anonymous gypsysmom said...

I'm voting for Joseph Boyden this time around. Three Day Road took us through the hell of the trenches and then in Through Black Spruce we saw the fallout of the decision to remove children from their homes and parents and move them to residential schools. I can't think of two more difficult subjects to write about but Boyden did it brilliantly.

Tuesday, 02 February, 2010  
Blogger Remi said...

I'll dive in at the last moment. Three Day Road wasn't near as good as I'd hoped it would be. I think Boyden can be great. He just has to stop trying so hard. MacDonald for me.

Tuesday, 02 February, 2010  

Tuesday, January 26, 2010

Reader's Diary #571- Robert Louis Stevenson, Adapted by Alan Grant and Illustrated by Cam Kennedy: Kidnapped

Over at the Graphic Novels Challenge blog, people have signed up to read more graphic novels this year. Offering many levels of commitment (3, 4-10, 10+), it's a great place for those who are just graphic novels curious or for those who are genuine fanatics. I joined last year, again this year, and am probably somewhere in between. I really liked the idea of a mini-challenge they ran in January: to read a graphic novel interpretation of a classic, so when I was at the library and came across Alan Grant and Cam Kennedy's version of Robert Louis Stevenson's Kidnapped, I knew I just had to grab it.

However, I haven't read the original and now I'm not sure if I'd made the right choice. I enjoyed it well enough; Kennedy's artwork was great and his sketchy traditional action comics style fit the fast paced adventure. Likewise, I enjoyed the Grant's fast paced version of Stevenson's book. At first it even seemed ludicrously fast, jumping from one peril right into another and I began to worry that none of the pieces would connect-- though fortunately it all came together in the end. But now I question whether or not Stevenson's original book was as energetic. It's certainly portrayed as a plot driven book, but what if Stevenson's was more character driven? It shouldn't matter, I guess, if I enjoyed Grant and Kennedy's take, but I feel almost as if I cheated, like I read a Reader's Digest Condensed Version. The other problem is that I'm less likely to go back and check. I mean, I already know the gist of the story at least, it's hard to find motivation in that. From now on, if I read a graphic novel interpretation, I'm going to read the original beforehand.

Labels: , , , , ,

Blogger arcona said...

Even if you've read the graphic novel, I'm encouraging you to read the original. RLS is a good writer whose style survives the passage of time - Kidnapped was my first RLS book and made me a fan. Knowing the story does not take away from the book.

Tuesday, 26 January, 2010  
Blogger John Mutford said...

I'm sure I will eventually, but I'm more likely to read his other stuff first now.

Tuesday, 26 January, 2010  
Blogger Barbara Bruederlin said...

I remember our teacher reading Kidnapped to us in elementary school and it was ripping enough to keep us rivetted. But I really don't recall too much about it so perhaps I should read the graphic novel.

Tuesday, 26 January, 2010  

Monday, January 25, 2010

Reader's Diary #570- Nicola Slade: My Dear Miss Fairfax


A couple weeks ago, Nan over at Letters From a Hill Farm reviewed Nicola Slade's short story "My Dear Miss Fairfax." Her review caught the eye of a few of us short story aficionados. Perhaps it was Nan's enthusiasm, perhaps it was that it was Slade's story is in epistolary form and that's not something you come across that often in a short story. Whatever the initial attraction, Teddy Rose decided to have her say on the story last week and now I'm getting in on the action.

In Teddy's review, she refers to Slade's story as "charming." That made me nervous. "Charming" is one of those words that makes me think of doilies, and tea cozies, and Jane Austen. Please, if you're a doily and tea cozy person who loves Jane Austen, don't bother writing me angry letters, it's nothing personal. I live in a double wide trailer-- I'm really not being a snob (except to those single wides--- pffft). It's just a personal preference thing, I like a bit more edge in my stories than "charming" would describe.

So was "My Dear Miss Fairfax" charming? Absolutely. But I'll give Slade credit for pulling off the epistolary form in such a limited space. And it did hold my attention. It is the story of Ambrose Rogers, a British plantation owner living in the West Indies. He writes to a lady friend named Selina Steyne, living back in London, asking to be paired up with a lady, any lady in fact, to be his wife. Turns out that Selina knows just the woman and has them meet through letters of their own before meeting in person. It's charming, so you know it has a happy ending (and for what it's worth, my issue is with "charming" not with "happy.")

I found myself comparing it to modern day romances that have developed over the Internet and how Slade's tale could just as easily be told today, only with a huge overhaul of the language.

Lady Steyne has painted a most agreeable picture of you= My BFF Steyne told me that ur hawt! LOL ;)

Yeah, at least charming isn't nauseating.

(Did you write a post for Short Story Monday? If so, please leave a link in the comments below.)

Labels: , ,

Blogger Nan said...

So glad you took the time to read it, and that you even liked it, oh edgy one! Loved your 'new' version. :<) And fyi(!) I don't like tea or Jane A. My short story this week is by Virginia Woolf:

http://lettersfromahillfarm.blogspot.com/2010/01/short-story-mondaya-haunted-house-by.html

Monday, 25 January, 2010  
Blogger John Mutford said...

Nan: Yes, I guess a guy who runs a book blog has no edgy bragging rights. But I did once eat some yogurt that was a day past the expiration date-- that's pretty rebellious, don't you think?

Monday, 25 January, 2010  
Blogger JoAnn said...

I do like Jane Austen, but am neutral to negative on tea cozies and doilies. The idea of an epistolary short story is so intriguing... maybe I shoud review it next week ;-)
Eudora Welty's "Why I Live at the P.O." was my choice today.
http://lakesidemusing.blogspot.com/2010/01/why-i-live-at-po-by-eudora-welty.html

Monday, 25 January, 2010  
Blogger Teddy Rose said...

John, I'm so glad you didn't gag on it. LOL! I rarely like romances myself but I did enjoy this one. I must admit I have never read Jane Austin, though I do enjoy the film version of her books. I just started watching a new adaption of "Emma" last night. However, I don't see myself devoting much time to reading her books.

After your review last week, I had to read "Ghost". Here is my review:http://teddyrose.blogspot.com/2010/01/ghosts-by-edwidge-danicat.html

Monday, 25 January, 2010  
Blogger John Mutford said...

JoAnn: Come now, no one can be neutral on tea cozies and doilies!

Teddy: Honestly, I've never seen an Austen adaptation, though I realize there are thousands.Looking forward to reading your review-- looks like we traded stories this week.

Monday, 25 January, 2010  
Blogger JoAnn said...

LOL...definitely negative on the doilies, but can't say as I've ever given tea cozies much thought!

Monday, 25 January, 2010  
Blogger B.Kienapple said...

I enjoy charming books, stories etc. but whenever I find myself applying that adjective I realize I've just ingested the literary equivalent of no-fat Kool Whip. Delicious but it makes you a bit ill thinking about what's in it.

Monday, 25 January, 2010  
Blogger Margot at Joyfully Retired said...

I remember that story when Nan posted it. I have it in my list to find and read.

I reviewed a short story today. You can find it at Joyfully Retired

Monday, 25 January, 2010  
Blogger Loni said...

I like edge and I also like Jane Austen. Here's my first review for Short Story Monday. I hope to keep contributing. As Birds Bring Forth The Sun by Alistair MacLeod.

http://loniseye.blogspot.com/2010/01/as-birds-bring-forth-sun.html

Monday, 25 January, 2010  
Blogger Nicola Slade said...

Love the updated version! And thank you, John, for such a great review.(For the record, I drink tea all the time, I'm English, after all, and a teacosy is an essential part of my armoury. I'm not big on doilies, but AM a Jane Austen fan).

I know what you mean about 'charming' but in mitigation, I should point out that the stories on my website were originally written for a UK women's magazine, where charming is fine!

(I've now turned to crime in my novel-writing so I'm not sure how the charm will hold up!)

Wednesday, 27 January, 2010  
Blogger John Mutford said...

B. Kienapple: I'd never thought of KoolWhip as charming before. Now meringue, on the other hand...

Margot: Yes, the story is getting around!

Loni: I guess Pride and Prejudice and Zombies was right up your alley then.

Nicola: Well, being a Newfoundlander, I drink my share of tea, too. I just don't like dressing up my teapot.

Always good to hear from an author! Especially ones I haven't offended.

Friday, 29 January, 2010  

Saturday, January 23, 2010

Saturday Word Play- Before and After Canadian Edition


A while ago I featured a Before and After game on Saturday Word Play, but since the CRTC has been on my back to make my blog more Canadian, I've revamped it so that each clue contains at least one Canadian book. Can you fill in the blanks to complete the two titles? Bonus points for naming the two authors. (Points can be redeemed at Snow Covered Hills for a free grammar lesson.)

As always, feel free to do all ten at home, but only answer one in the comment section below-- that way, at least nine others can play along.

1. Sea of ---------house five
2. Mercy Among --- -------- of Men
3. Green Grass, Running ----- for Elephants
4. Rebel ------ & Demons
5. Republic of ---- in the Time of Cholera
6. Running in the ------ Matters
7. The Watch That Ends --- ----- Before Christmas
8. Anne of --- ------ Walkers
9. Bottle Rocket ------ in Atlantis
10. Sleeping Dragons All ------ the World in 80 Days

Labels: ,

Blogger Kate said...

#4 Rebel Angels / Angels & Demons

And for my bonus point: Roberson Davies (one of my favourites) / Dan Brown (shudder)

Saturday, 23 January, 2010  
Anonymous gypsysmom said...

#3 is Green Grass, Running Water by Thomas King and Water for Elephants by Sara Gruen.

Both great books in my opinion.

Saturday, 23 January, 2010  
Blogger raidergirl3 said...

10. Sleeping Dragons All Around/ Around the World in 80 Days

Love Sheree Fitch! Sleeping Dragons is a wonderful book.

Saturday, 23 January, 2010  
Anonymous Pooker said...

#8 is Anne of the Island by L.M. Montgomery and The Island Walkers by John Bemrose

Saturday, 23 January, 2010  
Blogger Dale said...

1. Sea of Slaughter - Farley Mowat / Slaughterhouse Five - Kurt Vonnegut

Thank you for leaving an easy one for me! :-)

Sunday, 24 January, 2010  
Blogger John Mutford said...

Kate: That's it. I've only read one Davies book (Fifth Business) and two by Brown (cause apparently you can be hit by turd lightning twice).

Gyspysmom: Haven't read Gruen's yet, but I've heard good things.

Raidergirl: I met her about 10 years ago and she was very sweet in person.

Pooker: That's it.

Dale: Ahh Vonnegut. He puts the "laughter" in "slaughter". I don't really know what I mean by that, but I'm ran out of wit about 2 years ago. I don't really know what I mean by that either, but I'm scraping here.

Monday, 25 January, 2010  
Blogger Wanda said...

Not exactly Saturday but #2 is Mercy Among The Children by David Adams Richards / The Children of Men by P.D. James

Monday, 25 January, 2010  
Blogger B.Kienapple said...

#9 is Bottle Rocket HEARTS! Amazing book!

Monday, 25 January, 2010  
Blogger John Mutford said...

Wanda: That'd be it!

B.Kienapple: Yes, and of course the other title is HEARTS in Atlantis. Care to tell us the 2 authors?

Tuesday, 26 January, 2010  

Friday, January 22, 2010

Reader's Diary #569- Kenneth Yasuda: The Japanese Haiku

As someone who prefers his poems concise, I've long been attracted to haiku, though have never really given it the attention it deserved.

Actually, I've felt sorry for the haiku. It seems to be so misunderstood and abused by elementary school teachers who want a quick poetry lesson for the kids who've mastered syllables.

Fortunately Yasuda sheds some light on the topic. Where did the 5-7-5 come from? The Japanese didn't just pick those numbers at random. (And for all those who would say that the 5-7-5 is just an English approximation, Yasuda seems to think it is the best approximation.) 17 syllables, according to Yasuda is the average number of syllables that can be uttered in one breath, or in the Zen-like "haiku moment" the poet has experienced. Plus, the 5-7-5 arrangement adds a harmonious symmetry. Suggesting possibilities of haiku is English, Yasuda also recommends rhyming the first and last lines-- an impossibility in Japanese, but since the tool is available to English poets, could further tighten the symmetry.

Such discussions of technique make up the first half of Japanese Haiku and really made me appreciate the work and thought that should go into a real and good haiku. In the second half, Yasuda explores the history of the form, how it came to be, why the seasonal element is so crucial, why obviously metaphorical language is not recommended, and other points of interest. What I found particularly encouraging is that us westerners weren't the first ones to abuse the form. The haiku went through many troubled periods at the hands of the Japanese themselves, often because people took the short length for granted-- 17 syllables, who can't fire off one of those?

Occasionally I found Yasuda too rigid and critical, especially at the beginning of the book when he seemed to have it out for western imagist poets, showing for instance why a particular Basho haiku is superior to William Carlos Williams' "Red Wheelbarrow" poem and another time suggesting that Ezra Pound's "Metro" poem doesn't succeed. However, towards the end of the book, either he had lightened up or I came to appreciate the man's enthusiasm for and almost protective stance over the haiku.

Here's one the I wrote and worked on during the course of the book:

Slapping at insects-
The lake orange red purple
Fish, flies stop biting

It's not perfect, I know. I think it's too much of a story for the "haiku moment" Yasuda speaks of. There's a definite moment of understanding, but perhaps it's at the end of too long a narrative. Plus, it seems a little choppy. Essentially I have three moments: the onslaught of bugs, the sunset, the tranquility. As for Yasuda's suggestion of adding rhyme, I didn't as such, but I have added -ing words in the 5th and 7th line, though crossing over the poem instead of both at the end. I liked the idea of beginning and ending with similar words, thinking it might tighten up the whole passage of time issue. I've also gone for alliteration in the final line, trying to show a connection between me bothering the fish and the flies bothering me. Plus the "f" sound makes me think of air being released and energy subsiding. Finally, I played with punctuation in the second line, finding that the commas broke up the smoothness of a sunset transition. Anyway, here are much better haiku, taken from Yasuda's book:

Gentle Willow
Angry, I came home
And found within my garden
A willow-tree

-Ryota

Golden Maple Spray
City folk are they;
In the home-bound train they hold
Golden maple sprays.

- Meisetsu

The Galaxy
Wild the rolling sea!
Over which to Sado Isle
Lies the Galaxy.

- Basho

Labels: , , ,

Anonymous Liz in Ink said...

Thanks, John, for this. I spent last April writing a haiku a day and it got harder and harder the more I understood!

Friday, 22 January, 2010  
Blogger Diane Mayr said...

I haven't seen this book, but I will definitely look for it. I'm particularly disturbed by the suggestion of the use of end rhyme. The first thing that came to mind is trite and sing-songy. The examples you showed us from the book didn't change my mind!

Friday, 22 January, 2010  
Blogger Andromeda Jazmon said...

Yes, thanks for this post! I enjoyed your haiku and your discussion of it. I love your idea of starting and ending with similar words. I have been neglecting haiku lately and need to get back into it. Here is a challenge for me.

Friday, 22 January, 2010  
Blogger Barbara Bruederlin said...

That's quite fascinating. I had no idea of the whole philosophy behind the haiku, other than the 5-7-5 form.

Now I want to read and write more haikus. Look out, world.

Friday, 22 January, 2010  
Blogger kiirstin said...

I love haiku, and know next to nothing about it (other than being one of those students in a classroom told to write something in 5-7-5; I wonder where those went? probably away, for the good of all) I'll have to pick this up, although I will admit already to feeling shocked at someone dissing WCW.

Friday, 22 January, 2010  
Blogger Mary Lee said...

Welcome back, John! It's been awhile.

Interesting thoughts on haiku. I'm with Diane -- not convinced about the rhymes.

Friday, 22 January, 2010  
Anonymous madelyn said...

I love the short form, too. Even though it's structured, it seems less intimidating, somehow, knowing you just have those three lines. I love how people have used it for everything from nature to politics to humor (see the SPAM haiku archive...)
best, Madelyn

Friday, 22 January, 2010  
Blogger Dale said...

I only really knew the 5-7-5 rule as well. Thanks for the extra insight.

Sunday, 24 January, 2010  

Thursday, January 21, 2010

Reader's Diary #568- Katherine Paterson: Bridge to Terabithia

Published in 77, Newbery Medal winner in 1978, and yet somehow I missed this book, this now classic book, in my childhood. Do I regret having spent my time with Ralph S. Mouse and Bunnicula? Not a chance. Adulthood is a perfect time to go back and read those that got away. For the most part I've been using my kids as excuse for this task. Sorry kids, daddy's already read Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, let's read the BFG instead! I'm not that selfish, I swear! But just in case, this time I read Bridge to Terabithia on my own. Hearing that it's usually introduced in schools at an older grade, I didn't want to risk reading something to my kids that they aren't yet able to handle maturity-wise. (In retrospect, my daughter would have cried over this book, but handled it okay, whereas my son would have been bored to tears).

I enjoyed Bridge to Terabithia, with a few reservations. It is the story of two fifth grade kids, a boy and a girl named Jess and Leslie, that become inseparable, despite Leslie being new in town and coming from a family that doesn't quite fit the small town's mold. Terabithia is their imaginary kingdom, where Jess and Leslie work out their daily stressors and feel free to finally be themselves.

With the exception of his penchant for running, Jess was a boy I could totally relate to. Likewise, I'm sure many girls could relate to Leslie. Paterson did a wonderful job of creating believable characters.

I did think the story was a bit slow and unbalanced. Trying not to spoil the book, I will say that it revolves around a tragedy. However, the book is only 128 pages and the tragedy doesn't occur until page 102. It's all build up and little follow through. The build up is important in order to make the tragedy more palpable, but then Patterson attempts a resolution that felt rushed to me, a little like those 80s sitcoms when they'd attempt their serious episode, managing to curb a divorce, teach the dangers of drunk driving, and find the true meaning of Christmas all within 22 minutes. Well, maybe the ending of Bridge to Terabithia wasn't quite Growing Pains script, but I still think the build up could have been shaved down just a bit (I suspect many kids tune out before the drama happens), and the ending extended a little. Otherwise, I thought Bridge to Terabithia was a fine book.

Labels: , , ,

Blogger Kate said...

This is a book that I have always felt vaguely guilty for having never read. Great review - I'm sure that our library has a copy I can borrow.

Thursday, 21 January, 2010  
Blogger Wanda said...

I was in grade six in '78 and ordered BTT through Scholastic (Arrow?) Book Club. Read Island of the Blue Dolphins the same year; loved them both! Funny thing is, opposite of you, it wasn't 'til I had kids of my own that I discovered Bunnicula and the wonderful world of Beverley Cleary.

Monday, 25 January, 2010  

Wednesday, January 20, 2010

The Great Wednesday Compare #5- Ann-Marie MacDonald VERSUS Carson McCullers



The final winner of last week's Great Wednesday Compare (Ann-Marie MacDonald Vs Gabrielle Roy), with a final score of 5-4, was Ann-Marie MacDonald!

Last week's vote once again resulted in a tie, and so I cast the vote for Ann-Marie MacDonald. I had to do so for a couple reasons. One: Ann-Marie has a more varied portfolio; journalist, playwright, and novelist. Two: While I liked Gabrielle Roy's Tin Flute more than MacDonald's Fall on Your Knees, I really didn't enjoy Roy's collection of short stories, Children of My Heart. So, until I read something of MacDonald that I dislike more, my vote will have to go in her favour. By the way, last month I made a comment about not noticing what's on our Canadian money. I even reviewed a book about the carving pictured on the 20 dollar bill. But it was only while writing this post about Gabrielle Roy that I discovered there's a quote from her alongside the carving, "Could we ever know each other in the slightest without the arts?" Isn't that nice?

Anyway, this week we move out of Canada for the new contender.

Remember, vote simply by adding your comment below, base it on whatever merit you choose, voting does not end until Tuesday at 11:59 p.m. (Jan 27, 2009), and if you want your book to get more votes, feel free to promote them here or on your blog!

Who is better?

Labels: , ,

Blogger Barbara Bruederlin said...

I have actually never read Carson McCullers, although I think I may have started The Ballad of the Sad Cafe once. So I will go with MacDonald.

Wednesday, 20 January, 2010  
Blogger Teddy Rose said...

I've read both and still am standing by Ann-Marie MacDonald!

Wednesday, 20 January, 2010  
Blogger Kate said...

Sticking with Ann-Marie MacDonald! (There are very few authors out there that could convince me to vote against her.)

Wednesday, 20 January, 2010  
Blogger Nicola said...

I have only read two McCullers books so far (The Heart is a Lonely Hunter and The Member of the Wedding)but they have made me want to read everything she wrote so my vote goes to Carson McCullers.

Wednesday, 20 January, 2010  
Blogger Melwyk said...

Definitely Ann-Marie MacDonald for me!

Wednesday, 20 January, 2010  
Anonymous Pooker said...

Carson McCullers. I haven't read her in a long long time, but I remember her books fondly.

Saturday, 23 January, 2010  
Blogger Wanda said...

AMM for me!

Monday, 25 January, 2010  
Blogger B.Kienapple said...

I know it's probably not fair to vote since I haven't read anything by MacDonald but hell, I thought The Heart is a Lonely Hunter was chillingly excellent so I'm throwing in my two cents anyway.

Monday, 25 January, 2010  

Monday, January 18, 2010

Reader's Diary #567- Edwidge Danticat: Ghosts


With all the news out of Haiti lately, I thought I'd try to find a Haitian author to read. Until now I could name but one Haitian writer, Canada's slam poet Oni, the Haitian Sensation. Not that Haiti is a particularly large country, so I don't feel too embarrassed. There's plenty of bigger and more populous countries in which I couldn't name a single author. But, it's still sad that it takes an earthquake to make the world (self-included) to pay attention again. It's certainly not the only tragedy they've experienced.

Edwidge Danticat, a Haitian born author living in the US, speaks of those other tragedies in her short story "Ghosts". "Ghosts" is the story of Pascal Dorien, a young man living in Bel Air-- not quite a full-on slum, but certainly not Fresh Prince's home. This is Haiti. Gangs and corruption are the order of the day. Pascal, living with his parents, good people who run a local restaurant, dreams of starting a new radio show that would explore Bel Air's ganglife, create a dialogue, and lead to social activism.

However, Pascal's plans get sidetracked, no fault of his own. Danticat's "ghosts" represent wasted potential and sometimes the helplessness here is stifling. I gather this is realistic and serves as a great reminder that there's more than one mess that needs cleaning up in Haiti.

(Did you write a post for Short Story Monday? If so, please leave a link in the comments below.)

Labels: , ,

Blogger Barbara Bruederlin said...

I haven't read the entire story yet, but think she does a good job of drawing the characters and humanizing them. Shall be back to finish.

Monday, 18 January, 2010  
Blogger Margot at Joyfully Retired said...

I've "discovered" short stories and have decided to join you from time to time. My first short is up today.

You can find my post at Joyfully Retired

Monday, 18 January, 2010  
Blogger JoAnn said...

Excellent idea to highlight a Haitian author this week! I've got a couple of Danticat's books on my wishllist, but thanks to your link I'll start with this short story.

My story also came from The New Yorker. It's Jonathan Franzen's "Good Neighbors".
http://lakesidemusing.blogspot.com/2010/01/short-story-monday-good-neighbors-by.html

Monday, 18 January, 2010  
Blogger John Mutford said...

Barbara: Can't wait to hear what you think.

Margot: So wonderful to have you join us.

JoAnn: I have to give credit where credit is due, and that's to the New Yorker for consistently offering up so many short stories online.

Tuesday, 19 January, 2010  
Blogger Teddy Rose said...

Thanks for the link to this short John. I am also guilty. I have printed out the story to read.

Here's mine:http://teddyrose.blogspot.com/2010/01/my-dear-miss-fairfax-by-nicola-slade.html

Wednesday, 20 January, 2010  

Friday, January 15, 2010

Reader's Diary #566- Katsuhiro Otomo: Akira Volume 1

This March, the Mutfords are going to Japan!

Yes, it's an exciting time. And a strange time. See, while I love traveling and learning about different cultures, I'm kind of at a loss as to how Japan ended up topping our spring break travel plans. I've never been a huge fan of Japanese food, didn't quite get anime, and have somewhat of a phobia of insanely large cities. So why I'm ending up in Tokyo is a bit of a mystery. (I'm not shooting a whiskey commercial, I swear!)

But since making the decision a few months back, we've been trying to familiarize ourselves with Japanese culture as best we can in Canada's subarctic. I've come to realize that there's a huge variety of sushi, and have actually found quite a bit that I enjoy. I watched Ponyo, and okay, still don't get anime. But now I'm venturing down a new path for me: manga.

Not knowing where to start, I went for one of the biggies: Katsuhiro Otomo's Akira (Volume 1). Some have hailed it as one of the best graphic novels of all time. It's certainly one of the books that helped bring manga into the North American market.

What a relief! Not only did I really enjoy it, I'll be moving on to read the rest of the series, and new manga as well.

Set in a post-apocalyptic Neo-Tokyo (so when I visit today's Tokyo, I should actually be relieved), the story revolves around a young male biker gang that inadvertently gets caught up in a street war, a government cover-up, an illegal activist organization, and a whole lot of trouble. How? One night the gang explores a forbidden zone: the bombsite where World War Three essentially began. While there, one of the gang, Tetsuo, nearly runs into a pale childlike figure standing in the road. Tetsuo swerves, falls from his bike and is nearly killed. However, when he wakes up surrounded by strangers, he soon discovers he has new abilities...

The cyberpunk dystopia, the multi-layered mystery, the science fiction; I loved it. I was even surprised by how much I enjoyed the visuals. Growing up with crappy Astroboy cartoons (yeah, I said it), I thought Japan animation was overly and too simplistically stylized. However, the detail in Otomo's drawings was fantastic, especially in the decrepit and vandalized backdrops. Apparently when Marvel Comics bought the rights, they colourized it for publication in North America. However, since then Dark Horse comics has bought the rights and reverted it back to the original black and white, leaving only the first 16 pages colourized. I'm glad they left these pages in for the sake of comparison, and though painted by Otomo himself, I think black and white was the better choice. The graininess, essentially to the feel of Neo-Tokyo, seems to be lost with the colour and besides, the more graphic novels I read, the more I'm starting to think they should all be black and white-- I've yet to see one coloured well.

The only issue I have with Akira, and I'm hesitant to call it a problem, is the lack of a likable character. Kenada, while certainly the protagonist of the piece, is a rude punk at best, a dangerously violent teen at worst. But it's about the only character that could fit in this situation, so I'm not sure what choice Otomo had. Plus, there are five more volumes so there's definite room for growth.

Who knows, maybe when I'm done I'll watch the film version and grow to appreciate anime as well.

Labels: , , , ,

Blogger Bybee said...

Oh wow..you'll be really close...any plans to make a side trip to Seoul?

Friday, 15 January, 2010  
Blogger kiirstin said...

I'm really looking forward to hearing what you think of Japan! I've always kind of wanted to go, but also find that big cities, especially where I don't know the language, make me very nervous.

I haven't read Akira -- my manga tastes tend to run to the shojo (translated directly: "young girl" as in for young girls) and the sillier shojo at that.

And even if you didn't really like Ponyo, I still have to recommend Spirited Away by the same director. It won an Oscar, and it's beautiful. The subtitled version is best, and I get something new out of it each time I watch it. It's very much like a Japanese fairytale. But I admit, one just has to go with the flow occasionally because there are things that seem very odd. I think often it's because there's a cultural reference I'm missing entirely. Still love it, though, for its wonder and magic and beautiful art.

Friday, 15 January, 2010  
Blogger John Mutford said...

Bybee: Unfortunately no, not this around. It's a pretty jammed backed couple of weeks. But who knows what the future'll bring!

Kiirstin: A fellow traveller told me that the hardest adjustment for him upon visiting Japan was feeling illiterate. I must say, that intimidates me as well, but hey, as a teacher, maybe it'll be good to experience that feeling. As for the anime, I readily admit that I haven't seen a whole lot and it's most likely just that I haven't hit upon the right film for me.

Friday, 15 January, 2010  
Blogger Barbara Bruederlin said...

The trip is a go? Excellent! I'm trying to figure out how I can reinvent myself and get adopted as a Mutford.

I have not actually read any manga, but I know several teenage girls who are huge fans.

Friday, 15 January, 2010  
Blogger John Mutford said...

Barbara: Yes, the trip is a go. Things were looking financially tight there for a while, but we figured, if we come back bankrupt, we'll have still had a trip to Japan. That'll make the following year of Kraft Dinner and water go down much easier. As for the adoption, if you're toilet trained, no reinvention necessary.

Friday, 15 January, 2010  
Blogger Wanda said...

The trip sounds cool (minus the sushi :X !) and the book sounds interesting but I'll send my daughter your way for a more informed comment -- she's our resident Manga expert!

Saturday, 16 January, 2010  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

This is Wanda’s daughter :)
(what are you talking about Mama? sushi kicks ass.)
Much like you growing up on Astro-boy, I had Pokemon forced down my throat (ugh), and developed a huge bias towards Japanamation. Generally I grew up avoiding anything that even reminded me of it with the fear that I’d be a loser by association. But I realized it was horribly hypocritical of me to pride myself on my willingness to try anything and not try this.

I too would suggest Spirited Away, or anything associated with Hayao Miyazaki, but of course, there kids movies and I love kids movies. Im a kid. If your that interested in anime, check out “Grave of the Fireflies”, based on the semi-autobiographical novel of a man who survived the second world war (been trying to get the book, driving me crazy), “Paprika”, a very imaginative piece of work, and if you have the time “Cowboy Bebop”. Obviously I don’t know much about your tastes in a plot, but if you liked a story about a biker gang in post-apocalyptic Tokyo, perhaps you’ll like this. I like to think of it as a futuristic Mafia movie. Its a short, mostly character-driven series with a tone that changes from one part to another. The dialogue is A+, and they make very good use of angles, sound and transitions. If you do ever watch it, watch part five before making up your mind about it, and be very careful if you look it up. The ending to the series is common knowledge to basically anyone thats ever even heard of it, and a spoiler ruined the whole thing for me.

Also, I don’t know about you, but I hate the dubs of everything, and I’m a strong believer in the idea that foreign things should stay foreign. Most of these are unbearable in english. I always read the subtitles, and I would strongly suggest you do that if you plan to actually enjoy any of this haha. Also with subtitles, you usually get explanations of certain parts of Japanese culture which are omitted from an english version, such as traditions behind food, references to Shinto religion, and there wide system of honorifics.
Anyways, good luck, and have fun in Japan, I’m Jealous :)

-g

Saturday, 16 January, 2010  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

PS.
On the graphic novel front, I heard that Death Note was very good. I could never get a hold of it so I settled on watching the series. It caused a huge divide in its fanbase due to the differing morals of the two main characters, which is doubly interesting considering that the same divide appeared in the story itself. It also stirred up a lot of attention with its controversial themes and the resulting cases of copy cats that popped up around the world. Its plot is strange in that its arcs feel somehow disassociated, but still manage to carry you threw the whole thing. With the series I was un-impressed, but the complex story line and interesting characters made me feel that it had huge potential as, say, an 800 page novel, so perhaps the original manga was much better. but don’t quote me, lol :)
Oh and if I remember correctly, the english version of Akira was printed as a mirror so as to read from left to right, where as most manga are read from right to left, like Japanese vertical script. I don’t know which version you read, but just a heads up in case you start reading another one and wonder why there conversations are all backwards lol
-g

Saturday, 16 January, 2010  
Blogger John Mutford said...

Wanda: You've just to find the right sushi! I doubt they make California rolls in Japan, but it was the gateway sushi for us. Now we like a wide variety.

Wanda's Daughter: Thanks for your wonderful insight! My own kids are open to Japanese animation, for sure. My son, 4, loves Pokemon (definitely not forced on him though, because I don't understand it personally), and just this morning my daughter, 6, asked for the Ponyo DVD (which surprised me since I didn't realize she had enjoyed it that much). Thanks also for all the recommendations. Death Note in particular sounds very interesting. I'm going to try and hunt down a copy. Hey, you need to start a manga blog!

Saturday, 16 January, 2010  
Blogger Melwyk said...

How exciting - what an amazing trip that will be. I would love to visit Japan, but like you I am not sure the huge cities would be so wonderful. What I found when I went to Kyiv was the same thing you mentioned - that the worst part was suddenly being illiterate.
But it was still a fantastic experience.

As for the manga stuff, well, first off, Wanda's daughter has it covered. Second, I don't know much about it - the only film I've seen is Spirited Away, oh, and Howl's Moving Castle. I enjoyed them both.

Saturday, 16 January, 2010  
Blogger Melwyk said...

ps - Astroboy, hahaha

Saturday, 16 January, 2010  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

No prob :)
haha, im not THAT into it lol. You gotta sift threw loads of garbage to find good ones, but those good ones are worth it.
good luck finding a decent translation of deathnote, haha, and in your searches, watch out for insane fanatics, they can be quite frightening lol.
And hey, if you ever do watch Bebop, get back to me, id like to hear what you think :)
-g

Saturday, 16 January, 2010  

Wednesday, January 13, 2010

The Great Wednesday Compare #5- Ann-Marie MacDonald VERSUS Gabrielle Roy



The final winner of last week's Great Wednesday Compare (Ann-Marie MacDonald Vs Bernice Morgan), with a final score of 6-2, was Ann-Marie MacDonald!

This week we bid farewell to Bernice Morgan. It seems that a lack of popularity did her in, but at least the two who did vote for her were so enthusiastic that a few of the MacDonald fans promised to read Morgan (and we're holding them to it!) While I haven't read and can't say much about Morgan's latest offering and Canada Also Reads longlisted Cloud of Bone, I can say that her Random Passage and sequel Waiting for Time are considered classics back in Newfoundland. Beyond Newfoundland, the first book was also a national bestseller and the two books together generated a CBC miniseries back in 2002 starring Colm Meaney. The movie set was left standing and is now used as a historic tourist site. My wife and I had the opportunity to go there many summers ago and were even able to try on the costumes. Even if you haven't read the book or seen the movie, I'd recommend visiting.

This week we stick with our CanLit theme...

Remember, vote simply by adding your comment below, base it on whatever merit you choose, voting does not end until Tuesday at 11:59 p.m. (Jan 19, 2009), and if you want your book to get more votes, feel free to promote them here or on your blog!

Who is better?

Labels: , ,

Blogger Kate said...

Sticking with Ann-Marie MacDonald!

Wednesday, 13 January, 2010  
Blogger Nicola said...

OK, finally back to someone I've read!

Gabrielle Roy, for my vote.

Wednesday, 13 January, 2010  
Blogger raidergirl3 said...

(Cloud of Bone is excellent! I heard Morgan read from it too)

vote for... MacDonald I guess. I haven't read the other guy. Is he related to Patrick? :)

Wednesday, 13 January, 2010  
Blogger John Mutford said...

Raidergirl: That other guy is a woman actually. Um, guess I didn't pick the most flattering picture.

Wednesday, 13 January, 2010  
Anonymous gypsysmom said...

As good as Ann-Marie Macdonald is I'm voting for Gabrielle Roy. Her fiction always makes me nostalgic (and wish I had a teacher like her when I was growing up).

BTW, I missed last week's but I might have voted for Bernice Morgan. I read Random Passage by her last year and on the strength of that recommended Cloud of Bone to my book club so we're reading it for February.

Wednesday, 13 January, 2010  
Blogger Allison said...

Gabrielle Roy!

Thursday, 14 January, 2010  
Blogger Scrat said...

I have read and enjoyed works by both these authors. Nonetheless, I am sticking with Anne Marie Macdonald. Now if you put Camilla Gibb up against Anne Marie Macdonald, I would find this a much more difficult choice to make.

Friday, 15 January, 2010  
Blogger Wanda said...

AMM for me again, thanks!

Saturday, 16 January, 2010  
Anonymous Pooker said...

Okay, I'll make it interesting and vote for Gabrielle Roy. Not only is she wonderfully descriptive of people and place, I don't think I've ever seen any of the those seven words you can't say on television in her stories.

Plus, we share a birthday.

Tuesday, 19 January, 2010  

Tuesday, January 12, 2010

Reader's Diary #565- Michael Kenyon: the Beautiful Children

On the back cover of Michael Kenyon's The Beautiful Children, in the top left hand cover is the word novel. Not a novel, like on the cover, just novel.

The further into Kenyon's book and the more I began to think of the other meaning of the word: new and original. Certainly it is like no other book I've ever read. Not quite magical realism, not quite stream-of-consciousness, it's quite difficult for me to describe. Poetic, yes, but not a novel in verse either.

"Happiness is a brilliant house tumbling through the dark."

What does one do with such phrases as these? This is not an easy read. Nor should it be, sometimes we readers like a challenge, but at this point, after a single reading, I'm not sure that I can say I enjoyed it. For an experimental book, I was grateful that it was short. I at least avoided the lab rat feeling that haunted me with Kenneth J Harvey's latest and massive Blackstrap Hawco. It's also more consistent than Harvey's who'd come up just short of writing a chapter in semaphore flags. But then again, perhaps Kenyon's is too consistent. Everyone talks in a crazy sort of hallucinogenic haze that I just wasn't able to connect with. They'd hover close to lucidity enough so that I got the gist of their plot, but I certainly didn't relate. And about the only emotion I felt throughout the whole book was revulsion. What is it with people using the word "beautiful" for ironic purposes? Sam Mendes' American Beauty. Marilyn Manson's "Beautiful People." Leonard Cohen's Beautiful Losers. Good Lord, some of the ugliest imagery in the world comes from this collection. Now add Kenyon's book. Full of remorseless violence, drug addiction, and hopelessness, I don't think Kenyon will win the Stephen Leacock Award any time soon.

I needed a break, at least one character to come through for me. One that spoke in a voice that was normal. One that didn't see snakes in her veins and dream of chaos. One that wasn't stifling. One that I could embrace. Instead I got egg symbolism. Omelets thrown to a drowning man.

But here's why I think it's an important book. It is novel. I was reminded of a thought I had when I first encountered the poetry of bpNichol: if art is to evolve, we need mutations. If they prove beneficial, great. Plenty of mutations prove to be pointless, but we can't always know in the present day. Que será será.

Labels: , , ,

Blogger Barbara Bruederlin said...

You are right, of course, we do need novel works in order for art to evolve. But somehow I get the feeling that I will be too lazy to suffer through this. But that's my own fault.

Tuesday, 12 January, 2010  
Blogger Wanda said...

"Happiness is a brilliant house tumbling through the dark."

I suppose that could be true if it lands on The Evil Witch of the East, not so good for said witch though.

The cover is so striking, I was wondering about this one ... not sure what I'd make of it's contents. I enjoy stream-of-consciousnes poetry when presented as a poem or two within a collection. However, trying to digest an entire volume can be a little hard on the head. Glad you read this one first! If I see it, I'd likely pick it up just out of curiosity but I don't think I'll seek this one out.

Saturday, 16 January, 2010  

Monday, January 11, 2010

Reader's Diary #564- Robert J Sawyer: Forever


Just a couple or so years ago, if you'd asked me to name some Canadian genre fiction authors, I'd have drawn a blank. It existed, of course, but I was out of the loop. But thanks to the miracle of blogging, I can now throw them out like candy at a Santa Claus parade (sorry, my holidays were too short): Linwood Barclay, Kelley Armstrong, Guy Gavriel Kay, Robert J Sawyer...

But naming them is just the first step. Now I have to read them. Thanks to Robert J Sawyer having the good sense to offer up a few short stories on his website, I'll start with him. If I like it, I'll bump Calculating God further up on my tbr pile (I have unread books by all the aforementioned authors sitting on my bookshelf).

I decided to go with a story called "Forever" about a species of humanly intelligent dinosaurs that has just discovered a meteor on its way to possibly destroy them all. It begins with a pseudo-quote from a scientist at a paleontologist meeting in 2018 who talks about the rather small sample of dinosaurs we're actually aware of. Even had we found all the fossils on Earth, we'd probably only know a fraction of what had actually lived as many parts of the Earth were not conducive to fossilization.

Why is it when anyone mentions that life probably exists elsewhere in the universe, most people assume it's intelligent life? And usually of human level intelligence or higher? Couldn't there be a planet full of bacteria and nothing more? How about one where the smartest animal is no brighter than a turkey? In any case, Sawyer seems to use the more popular line of thinking: if there were many other unknown dinosaurs on Earth, maybe they were intelligent! Yeah, well maybe. It is fun to consider though and if that's the sole reason for the story, it delivers.

However, try to fine something more profound, say for instance that this is a parable for modern man and how the drive for ego gratification might just save us from impending doom, and the story isn't anything special. Quite frankly, there are times when it feels like Sawyer's going through the sci-fi motions-- "I'm not completely thirty-six thirty-sixths certain, Your Highness," Cholo says at one point-- but though the story is all premise, it's at least short and entertaining while it lasts.

So does Calculating God get bumped up the tbr pile? No, at this point Barclay is in the lead. I will read a Sawyer novel eventually, but I'll be expecting more.

Did you write a post for Short Story Monday? If so, please leave a link in the comments below.

*In other exciting short story news, Kate has revived the A Curious Singularity website. For more details, click here.)

Labels: , ,

Blogger JoAnn said...

I need to read more Canadian authors, but a story about "a species of humanly intelligent dinosaurs..." doesn't appeal to me at all - lol!

Thanks for mentioning A Curious Singularity - have gone over and signed up. I read a story by Colm Toibin this week:
http://lakesidemusing.blogspot.com/2010/01/short-story-monday-color-of-shadows-by.html

Monday, 11 January, 2010  
Blogger Nan said...

I read a lovely story online this Monday:

http://lettersfromahillfarm.blogspot.com/2010/01/short-story-mondaymy-dear-miss-fairfax.html

And I think I mentioned that I've joined A Curious Singularity. I love short stories and am please to find others who do as well.

Monday, 11 January, 2010  
Blogger John Mutford said...

JoAnn: No I don't imagine the dinosaur tale is for everybody!

Nan: Glad you're joining us at A Curious Singularity!

Monday, 11 January, 2010  
Blogger Teddy Rose said...

I think I will skip this story John. It doesn't sound like my cuppa. You already found my short:
http://teddyrose.blogspot.com/2010/01/chicxulub-by-t-coraghessan-boyle-and.html

Monday, 11 January, 2010  

Saturday, January 09, 2010

Saturday Word Play- The Rock Bottom Remainders Suggested Cover Tunes


So why let Russell Crowe, Keanu Reeves, and Juliette Lewis have all the fun? Actors aren't the only ones doing what they have no business doing playing in a rock and roll band. Back in the early 90s a group of (mostly well known) writers got together to form a supergroup of sorts (super being used loosely-- one member is quoted as saying, "we play music as well as Metallica writes novels"). But, despite a lack of musical talent, they've raised a lot of money for charity over the years, gotten to play with the likes of Bruce Springsteen, Warren Zevon, and... Frank McCourt. Perhaps you've heard of them: they're the Rock Bottom Remainders. But can you name some of the past and present members?

Below I've given you 10 lists of songs that the Rock Bottom Remainders haven't covered (as far as I know), but might as well try (another quote from the band: "We know about 3 or 4 songs. But we play about 50"). Each list will give you a clue as to one of the authors. One word in each song in the list is also part of a book title. Figure out the title, then identify the author. For instance, if I gave you this list:

Eli, the Barrow Boy- the Decemberists
Church of the Poison Mind- Culture Club
Knock on Wood- Amii Stewart
Neon Bible- Arcade Fire

You could pick the, poison, wood, Bible from the song titles and know that I'm looking for Barbara Kingsolver, author of The Poisonwood Bible and once a member of the Rock Bottom Remainders.

As always feel free to do all ten at home, but only answer one in the comment section. That way nine more people will have a chance to play along.

1.
The End- the Doors
Joy to the World- Three Dog Night
Hard Luck Woman- Kiss
Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band- the Beatles

2.
The Sign- Ace of Base
Five Feet High and Rising- Johnny Cash
People are People- Depeche Mode
Don't You (Forget About Me)- Simple Minds
We'll Meet Again- Vera Lynn
Once in a Lifetime- Talking Heads
Stairway to Heaven- Led Zeppelin

3.
War Pigs- Black Sabbath
Back in Black- AC/DC
Monkey Gone to Heaven- the Pixies

4.
Papa's Got A Brand New Bag- James Brown
Can't Get You Out of My Head- Kylie Minogue
Little Bones- the Tragically Hip

5.
Ordinary Day- Great Big Sea
My Heroes Have Always Been Cowboys- Willie Nelson

6.
Everyday I Write the Book- Elvis Costello
One of Us- Abba
Bad Moon Rising- Creedence Clearwater Revival
The Songs That We Sing- Charlotte Gainsbourg

7.
After the Gold Rush- Neil Young
Big Bottom- Spinal Tap
Open Book- the Rakes
Sisters of Mercy- Leonard Cohen
Straight to Hell- the Clash

8.
Black Boys on Mopeds- Sinead O'Connor
Many Rivers to Cross- Jimmy Cliff

9.
Color Me Impressed- the Replacements
Jigsaw Puzzle of Life- Kate and Anna McGarrigle
Don't Drink the Water- Dave Matthews Band

10.
Alphabet St.- Prince
Gin & Juice- Snoop Dogg

Too hard? Then maybe you can just figure out one of the titles and add that to the comment section. Someone else might recognize the author.

Labels: ,

Blogger Andersen said...

#4, since he's my favorite of the Remainders: "Bag of Bones," by Stephen King

Saturday, 09 January, 2010  
Blogger raidergirl3 said...

#2 - The Five People You Meet in Heaven - Mitch Albom

well, the things you learn about when playing the Saturday Word Play!

Saturday, 09 January, 2010  
Blogger Wanda said...

#1 is The Joy Luck Club ~ Amy Tan

Saturday, 09 January, 2010  
Anonymous arcona said...

#3. War in Heaven - Charles Williams

Saturday, 09 January, 2010  
Blogger John Mutford said...

Andersen: That's it. And mine too.

Raidergirl: If I can help just one person get that brown piece of pie in Trivia Pursuit than I know my time on this Earth hasn't been wasted.

Wanda: That's right. One of the long term members.

Arcona: Sorry, that was a bit of a tricky one. War in Heaven is there, and it is by Charles Williams, but he wasn't a Rock Bottom Remainder member. It's tricky for another reason, too...

Saturday, 09 January, 2010  
Blogger Remi said...

I'm thinking the answer to 3 is Pigs In Heaven. Drawing a blank on the author, though.

Really tough one this week. Nice.

Saturday, 09 January, 2010  
Blogger John Mutford said...

Remi: Pigs in Heaven is the title.

Saturday, 09 January, 2010  
Anonymous Pooker said...

#7 - The Big Book of Hell by Matt Groening

Saturday, 09 January, 2010  
Anonymous gypsysmom said...

I know that Pigs in Heaven is by Barbara Kingsolver but I'm blanking on any of the rest of the titles. Like raidergirl3 I had never heard of the Rock Bottom Remainders but it sounds like fun.

Saturday, 09 January, 2010  
Blogger John Mutford said...

Pooker: That's it. Groening, of course, while one of the most well known in the band, doesn't immediately come to mind when one thinks of authors, though he has loads of titles under his belt. The Big Book of Hell being a compilation of his Life in Hell comics.

Gypsysmon: Yes, it was Barbara Kingsolver. Tricky to some perhaps because she was also the author I used in my example. I remember hearing about the RBRs when they first formed. I was still in highschool at the time and well into my Stephen King phase, so the news captured my attention. I didn't know they still performed until doing this post. However, the last date on their website is 2007 so I don't know if they've called it quits or not.

Saturday, 09 January, 2010  
Blogger Barbara Bruederlin said...

This is a fun one!

#5 is Ordinary Heroes by Scott Turow?

Saturday, 09 January, 2010  
Blogger John Mutford said...

Barbara: Glad you enjoyed it, and yes, that's the right answer.

Sunday, 10 January, 2010  

Friday, January 08, 2010

Reader's Diary #563- Neil Christopher and illustrated by Larry MacDougall: Stories of the Amautalik

I was pretty excited to learn recently of a new Inuit-owned publishing company out of Iqaluit, Nunavut known as Inhabit Media. As those Canadian Book Challenge participants who have tried to read a book from each province and territory can tell you, the selections from Nunavut are slim pickins.

Hopefully Inhabit Media will help change that. Right now they have a limited number of books in their catalogue, but they were nice enough to send me three of them to review. The first of these is Stories of the Amautalik, researched and written by Neil Christopher and illustrated by Larry MacDougall. A translator, Louise Flaherty, is also mentioned on the cover of my book but I think she must have done the Inuktitut version of the book as according to the Inhabit website, Neil Christopher is English.

Reading Christopher's author bio brought back memories for me. Like him, I moved to Nunavut to teach, fresh out of teachers' college. Also like him, my first introduction to Inuit mythology was a student telling me of Mahaha, the tickle monster. No, not Elmo. This one tickles you to death.

I wanted to learn more and more about the myths and legends, but admittedly didn't try as hard as I should have. I've since learned of the qallupilluit, through the Robert Munsch/ Michael Kusugak collaboration; the Ijiraq, again through Michael Kusugak's Hide and Sneak; and of course Sedna the sea-goddess who goes by different names across the Arctic with slightly different stories attached.

The amautaliit I haven't heard of. These are described as ogresses who travel the tundra looking for people, usually children, to eat. Once kidnapping her victims, she usually transports them back to her lair in a basket on her back or in the back pouch of her amauti (a type of parka). Like most ogres and ogresses she's also dirty, foul-smelling and full of bugs. But she also has rancid seaweed with her, which is a nice touch for an arctic ogre, don't you think? Fortunately, most stories show her to be a little on the not-so-bright side, so escape is at hand.

In Stories of the Amautalik Christopher shares two legends. The first, and longer of the two, deals with two boys, Alliq and Makpalu, who are teasing a younger girl named Kunaju, when the three of them are taken by surprise by a hungry amautalik. Kunaju saves the day by staying brave and using a magical amulet that had been passed down to her. However, since they stink so bad and are covered in bugs from their ride in the nasty basket, they have to remain out of the community until they have freshened up. It gives the boys time to reflect upon the value of this little girl whom they'd treated so poorly and they wind up, to Kunaju's surprise, apologizing.

In the second story a quick thinking orphan named Aviuq wiggles a toe through his shoddy kamik and pretends it is a sleeping monster to scare away a cowardly amautalik.

It's interesting to note that since these two legends came from two regions of the Arctic, MacDougall has chosen to draw them differently. It was either well planned or just fortunate that they matched the amautalik characters up the way they did. The first is definitely the scarier story of the two (no more than the witch in Hansel and Gretal, mind you), but the edge is taken off somewhat by the more buffoonish-looking ogress. On the other hand, the skull-faced amautalik in the second story could be down right terrifying were it not for the rather comical story she finds herself in. The way it is, I think the book has a much better balance. My only complaint is that I'd have liked more illustrations. 16 illustrations in a 48 page picture book doesn't seem like a lot, especially when they're so well done.

I'm looking forward to reading more from Inhabit Media.

Labels: , , , , , ,

Blogger Scrat said...

Sounds like it could be very interesting! I went to the website and checked out Inhabit Media site -- way COOL!!!
Thanks for broadening my horizons!

Friday, 08 January, 2010  
Blogger Wanda said...

My children and I have always enjoyed books about Inuit and First Nations mythology. I'll suggest this as a library purchase where it will hopefully find it's way into the hands of more children. How Eagle Got His Good Eyes and Hide and Sneak are great picture books but I'd love to come across more titles for middle grade readers. Any suggestions?

Saturday, 09 January, 2010  
Blogger John Mutford said...

Wanda: Kusugak's "Curse of the Shaman" is aimed at that age group-- haven't read it myself though.

Saturday, 09 January, 2010  
Blogger Teddy Rose said...

Thanks so much for the tip John. I am very interested too. I just checked and my library has it!

Monday, 11 January, 2010  

Wednesday, January 06, 2010

The Great Wednesday Compare #5- Ann-Marie MacDonald VERSUS Bernice Morgan



The final winner of last week's Great Wednesday Compare (Dennis Lee Vs Ann-Marie MacDonald), with a final score of 3-1, was Ann-Marie MacDonald!

Saying goodbye to Dennis Lee this week, I would like to encourage those of you who haven't read his adult poetry to do so. I know you're probably all sick of eating "Alligator Pie," but you know that his alligator is also his cash cow and so it pops up in just about every Canadian anthology of children's poems. I'd withhold the pie just to see if that 2nd line is true, just about now. (By the way, I ate alligator on New Year's Eve, and it ain't that special.) Read his adult poetry, it shows that he's much, much more.

Moving on to this week's new contender, I feel a little explanation is in order. No doubt many among you (actually, with my readers, I shouldn't assume anything), are much more familiar with Ann-Marie MacDonald. Both of her novels have been shortlisted for a Giller, while the first, Fall on Your Knees, won the Commonwealth Prize for Best First Novel and was an Oprah pick. It's also a contender for Canada Reads 2010. And there's the rub. It and Generation X, in particular, seem to have alienated some faithful Canada Reads contenders for being too well known already. Whether they also felt cheated out of new and exciting books, or whether capitalizing on those that truly felt that way, the National Post enters the scene promising to come to the disenchanted rescue. But will this be a case of the Weakest Link versus Who Wants To Be a Millionaire? (And in case that's too subtle, I mean to ask that next year, will we not care about either competition?) Time will tell. In the meantime, their longlist is certainly compelling. For the most part there are some exciting choices on there (go Steve Zipp!) but did the person who nominated Alice Munro not get it? She's even had a book on Canada Reads for cripes sake! Let's see, how can we make this competition better and more exciting than the original? By championing the same authors? Fail! Anyway, that's officially my 100th Alice Munro rant so I should move on to the other contender this week: Bernice Morgan. Who? If you've read her, you've probably enjoyed her. If not, I guess she has her work cut out for her this week. She can also be found on the Canada Also Reads longlist. Canada Reads versus Canada Also Reads? Nah. That'd be getting carried away. But if Alice Munro (gripe #101) makes the shortlist, you might just see my own version: Canada Also Reads, Too.

Remember, vote simply by adding your comment below, base it on whatever merit you choose, voting does not end until Tuesday at 11:59 p.m. (Jan 12, 2009), and if you want your book to get more votes, feel free to promote them here or on your blog!

Who is better?

Labels: , , , , ,

Blogger Barbara Bruederlin said...

I have not read Bernice Morgan. I have read Ann-Marie MacDonald, and enjoyed many aspects of her books, not so much others. Sooooo, I'll go with Alice Munro.

Okay, Ann-Marie MacDonald.

Wednesday, 06 January, 2010  
Blogger John Mutford said...

Barbara: You got off with a tongue lashing by that much.

Wednesday, 06 January, 2010  
Blogger Kate said...

Voting for Ann-Marie MacDonald again (and I would even vote for her against Alice Munro). As I mentioned last week, Fall on Your Knees is one of my long-standing favourites (despite the Oprah recommendations).

Wednesday, 06 January, 2010  
Blogger Remi said...

I love the NP list, Alice Munro included. Her book does qualify, oddly enough (published in last two years and not a winner of a major Canuck prize).

Going through that list, I find a lot of books I've been excited about - Helwig's Girls Fall Down and Grant's Come, Thou Tortoise in particular. It's a lot more fun than the Canada Reads list.

Of course, the NP list is about preaching to the choir. I wonder if that's part of the problem. Canada Reads is a program that gets listened to by people who might not be so obsessed with Canuck small presses and lesser known writers. If CR presented our collective dreamlist of somewhat obscure writers, would anybody really care? Or listen? Outside of a small circle of friends, that is? (to steal a line from Phil Ochs).

As for the challenge, I'm at a loss - seeing Dennis Lee getting deposed in such a perfunctory manner really hurts. I'll go with MacDonald because she, like Coupland, was born on a Canadian Forces base in Germany.

Wednesday, 06 January, 2010  
Blogger John Mutford said...

Kate: Hey, Oprah's picked some great books. I wouldn't say "despite." ;)

Remi: Yeah, I know it hasn't won a prize but even she removed herself from the Giller list. I'm just saying that the whole critique about Canada Reads not picking exciting contenders would be moot if they had another Munro book. I know I've singled her out but Helen Humphreys is also on there and one of her novels was also a Canada Reads contender a few years back. I see your point about preaching to the choir, and I don't think they need to go completely indie and obscure. I've enjoyed Canada Reads over the years and the argument has come up a lot when big names get petitioned. Atwood and Richler didn't stand a chance (and despite Richler being popular, I think Barney's Version deserved to win that year. Popular or not, it was the better book). But this year they've got two really popular books, and people do like reading something they may not have heard of before or were unlikely to pick up without the incentive. Plus Wayson Choy's book isn't exactly obscure, though I don't think it's a poor choice. Still I would think most people are excited about Endicott and Dickner.

Wednesday, 06 January, 2010  
Blogger Scrat said...

Well normally I don't weigh in on these debates but this week's is just too tempting.
I absolutely love everything Anne Marie MacDonald has written. I don't know the other author and have no strong feelings about Alice Munro.
I loved Good to a Fault and Come thou tortoise -- so it is exciting to see these books get some attention too.

Wednesday, 06 January, 2010  
Blogger raidergirl3 said...

Bernice Morgan.
Bernice Morgan.
Bernice Morgan.

that's one vote for each of her three marvelous books. No? not allowed?
How about one for each of my children voting? no?

Random Passage, Cloud of Bone and Waiting for Time should be considered some of our Canadian history reads, and so many more people should read them.

(can you tell I'm a fan?)

Wednesday, 06 January, 2010  
Blogger Teddy Rose said...

Bernice Morgan is on my TBR but I haven't read anything by her yet. Therefore, I'm going with John Mutford, I'm a big fan

Oh, he's not in the running? Okay, Ann-Marie MacDonald.

Wednesday, 06 January, 2010  
Anonymous arcona said...

Raidergirl3 just referred me to this contest because she knows I have strong opinions about both these authors. I read Bernice Morgan's Random Passage last year and think its a wonderful novel for both its writing and strength - I recommend it to anyone who asks. I just finished Ann-Marie MacDonald's Fall on Your Knees for Canada Reads, and while the writing is extremely good, she just piles misery upon misery and leaves everyone with absolutely no hope. I wouldn't recommend it to anyone because of the unending unhappiness in her book. My first clue that it would be dreary was the "Oprah" seal on the cover and I wasn't disappointed. I strongly vote for Bernice Morgan. To those of you who voted for Ann-Marie MacDonald because you haven't read Bernice Morgan, I can guarantee that when you've read both these authors, you'll pick Bernice Morgan.

Wednesday, 06 January, 2010  
Blogger John Mutford said...

Scrat: Glad to see this one got you involved!

Raidergirl: I recall you mentioning how big a Morgan fan you are. You were the one that brought Cloud of Bone to my attention (though I've still not read it!)

Arcano: Whoever Raidergirl sends this way will be my guest. Come back at anytime.

Wednesday, 06 January, 2010  
Blogger Sandra said...

I loved both of McDonald's novels and voted for her in the last Compare. But I haven't read Morgan at all so a very one-sided vote it would be for me. I feel I have to abstain this time around, sorry John. But...after reading the comments (great discussion by the way) by those who know Morgan's work I will make it a point to read at least one of her novels this year.

Thursday, 07 January, 2010  
Blogger Wanda said...

Love, love, love the work of Ann-Marie MacDonald! An actress, playwright, journalist, novelist, T.V host and lyrisist — is there anything this woman can't do?! AMM gets my vote but wow, after reading comments in this string, will definitely be checking out Bernice Morgan.

Saturday, 09 January, 2010  

Tuesday, January 05, 2010

Reader's Diary #562- Jeff Smith: The Great Cow Race & Eyes of the Storm

Last year, just as I was discovering my love for graphic novels, my son was showing an interest in comics. I missed out on the comics as a kid, so it's a world I'm totally in support of him exploring as long as he takes me along for the ride. However, finding appropriate comics for a four year old isn't always easy, especially since Marvel Super Hero Squad doesn't publish nearly often enough:And besides, I'm more of an alternative comics guy (I am still a literary snob, n'est pas?) so the Bone books make us both happy.

The Great Cow Race didn't impress me as much as the first in the series. But I think I had the same thing happen as when I read the 2nd in the Harry Potter series. Once the thrill of meeting the new world for the first time had passed, expectations ran a bit a too high. Not that there is anything drastically wrong with the Great Cow Race, it has Smith's wonderful mix of adventure and comedy going for it after all, but I was a little impatient for the overall story to pick up.

Thankfully Eyes of the Storm delivered. There's genuine thrills in this book (some that I was concerned would be a little too scary for my son, but when he offered to make the thunder noises, I knew he'd be okay), and finally we get a little more character development and clues about what it is those nasty rat creatures are after, still holding back enough of the mystery to get us excited about the fourth installment.

Again, I love Smith's eclectic style. The Bones themselves seem cartoonishly oversimplified, looking like a cross between the Smurfs and Steamboat Willie, Thorn and the other human figures could come from any modern mainstream superhero comic, and the rat creatures look like they come from a Manga version of hell (I'd say they look like one of the scarier Pokemon characters, but unless you're a father of a four year old boy, that probably means even less to you).

It's quite an enchanting world and I can see why so many people are visiting.

Labels: , ,

Blogger Peta said...

I've been toying with the idea of buying the one volume (enormous) Complete Bone and I have to say that your reviews have made me think it's worth doing! I hope you and your son continue to enjoy the experience.

Wednesday, 20 January, 2010  
Blogger John Mutford said...

I just noticed today that such a volume exists. It'd definitely be the cheaper way to go. Do you know if it's colourized?

Thursday, 11 February, 2010  

Monday, January 04, 2010

Reader's Diary #561- T. C. Boyle: Chicxulub

Last week I compiled a list of short stories that I'd found online, read, and reviewed in 2009.When fellow blogger and Short Story Monday participant JoAnn wrote to tell me she had compiled a similar list, I just had to check it out. I'm a sucker for lists. Quickly scanning hers over, T.C. Boyle's "Chicxulub" caught my eye, probably because of its unfriendly-to-English-readers title. How do you pronounce that? Chicks-you-lub?

Anyway. Recently my wife and I were discussing our six year old daughter watching the first two Harry Potter movies. While we agreed there were parts she'd no doubt be scared over, I'd already read the books to her and we both felt that the experience served as a good buffer. Movies, we said, are typically scarier. Do you feel the same way? I think I find movies generally more emotional all the way around, yet for all that I prefer books. With books I can turn away, I can pace myself when the going gets rough.

JoAnn refered to Boyle's story as "one of the most powerful short stories I've ever read." I'd have to say that I'd agree, though I was thankful of the distractions around me: the cat, the phone, and especially the sounds of my kids playing. I'm glad I didn't read it alone at night in a silent house. It's not scary, at least not in the way that you think, but I was very early in when my heart nestled down into my throat and remained there until the end.

It's a brilliantly written story. Chicxulub, for those of you that don't know and clearly have not read Bill Bryson's A Short History of Nearly Everything, is one of a few sites mentioned by Boyle that meteors have wreaked destruction on Earth. Boyle intersperses this scary science with a tale of family tragedy to discuss fate and futility. Such comparisons could be heavy handed, overwrought, or down right clumsy. Boyle pulls it off beautifully by making you care. I love this story.

It seems that yet another blogger was responsible for bringing it to JoAnn's attention; from Nymeth, to JoAnn, to me, and next hopefully to one of you. It's really, really good. It deserves a online chain to keep it going.

(Did you write a post for Short Story Monday? If so, please leave a link in the comments below.)

Labels: , ,

Blogger Teddy Rose said...

This sounds like one that I have to read as well! Stay tuned for my review. For this week, I reviewed Natalie: http://teddyrose.blogspot.com/2010/01/natalie-by-anne-enright.html

Monday, 04 January, 2010  
Blogger Ali said...

I agree that the images in movies make them much more intense than books in some ways. On the other hand, I think reading something can have more impact on me emotionally. I internalize it more.

I finally got it together to do another Short Story Monday! Here's my thoughts on Brokeback Mountain.

Monday, 04 January, 2010  
Blogger Nan said...

Wow, what a description! I'll look into it. I did write about a short story today, and hope to continue each week.

http://lettersfromahillfarm.blogspot.com/2010/01/short-story-mondaythe-case-of-missing.html

Monday, 04 January, 2010  
Blogger John Mutford said...

Teddy: Looking forward to it!

Ali: Agreed. Books linger with me much longer than movies. And yes, that would probably be due to internalizing. Spending so much more time with a book, it allows for a much deeper reflection.

Monday, 04 January, 2010  
Blogger John Mutford said...

Ooops, sorry I missed you there Nan. Glad you're joining us!

Monday, 04 January, 2010  
Blogger Barbara Bruederlin said...

What an incredibly powerful story. It shook me to the core, to tell you the truth. I won't soon forget this one.

Monday, 04 January, 2010  
Blogger JoAnn said...

Isn't that just the most amazing story ever?? I could hardly breathe as I was reading. I'm so glad you got a chance to read it! (and I've been saying chic-ex-you-lub... but who knows?)

I have a story by Dorothy Whipple this week:
http://lakesidemusing.blogspot.com/2010/01/short-story-monday-lovely-time-by.html

Monday, 04 January, 2010  
Blogger Teddy Rose said...

Man John, I couldn't wait to read Chicxulub. I read it a couple nights ago and my heart is still in my throat! I just wrote my review of it and scheduled it to be posted on Monday. I was so impressed however, that I also made a mini challenge out of it, which I included in the same post.

Thursday, 07 January, 2010  
Blogger John Mutford said...

Barbara: Isn't it great?

JoAnn: Thank-you, thank-you for bringing it to my attention.

Teddy: Ooooh! I can't wait-- you have my curiousity piqued.

Thursday, 07 January, 2010  
Blogger John Mutford said...

Teddy Rose's Challenge here.

Monday, 11 January, 2010  
Blogger Teddy Rose said...

Thanks for the link John.

Monday, 11 January, 2010  

Sunday, January 03, 2010

Reader's Diary #560- William Shakespeare: King Henry the Fifth

In my very slow quest to read all the plays of Shakespeare, I've not really gone about it systematically. Basically I try to balance the plays I'm actually interested in reading against the history plays, hoping not to get stuck with a whole bunch of King Whoever plays at the end. It's not that I'm anti-history per se, but I've never had an interest in war; not movies, not books, nothing. I realize of course that learning about war is important, but I'm usually bored to tears with it. And that's what most of Shakespeare's king plays seem to be about.

So I've trudged through the three parts of King Henry VI and King Richard III. Not that there weren't parts or characters that I enjoyed (Queen Margaret was a pretty awesome villain), but not enough to get me excited about my next history play. So, I simply picked randomly from what was left and read King Henry V. In hindsight, and after doing (albeit minimal) research, King Henry V is the last of a tetralogy, after Richard II, Henry IV part 1 and Henry IV part 2. Reading those first might have increased my understanding and enjoyment.

I'm not quite sure why King Henry the Fifth was invading France and I certainly didn't care a whole lot (nothing against the French mind you, but Shakespeare's play didn't really rouse my emotions in anyone's favour). Nor did I care for King Henry's crazily rushed wooing of the king of France's daughter, Katharine at the end. The courtship wasn't amusing, wasn't angering, wasn't beautiful, wasn't much of anything except unbelievable. Katharine did, of course, end up marrying King Henry but I'm not so sure that Shakespeare adequately explains how or why it happened.

It wasn't a total waste of time though. I did enjoy Shakespeare's focus on languages in this play. First there was Fluellen, a Welsh captain in Henry's army. It was interesting to see Shakespeare's take on the accent, in particular replacing all his bs with ps as in pridges. Though he'd written other plays with characters of different cultures, I don't recall him ever writing to mimic the various accents. Imagine hearing Lady Macbeth saying "Oooot damn sput!" I assume this was done somewhat for comedy at the expense of the Welsh, though Fluellen does prove to be honorable and intelligent. There's also Katharine's attempts to learn English. Again, this was most likely for comedic purposes, especially as her attendant Alice gives her vocabulary lessons on English body parts. Yes, parts of that scene were amusing. I was also very surprised with the amount of French in the play and wondered what portion of his original audience would have understood-- not that it would have mattered too much. I didn't understand a lot and I still got the gist.

On a trivial note, I was surprised to see a reference to tennis in the play. I had no idea it had existed for so long. Thanks to Google, I've since learned that it has indeed but the version King Henry the Fifth would have played was much different than the game mastered by Venus and Serena today.

So there you have it. Not my favourite Shakespeare play but not my least either. And hey, I learned something.

Labels: , ,

Anonymous Christie said...

I think reading Shakespeare is a daunting task. I speak from experience because just before Christmas I finished reading Hamlet with a group of grade 12 students. *g* Like you, I found it particular hard to slog through the History plays. I am much more partial to the tragedies!

Sunday, 03 January, 2010  
Blogger Steve Zipp said...

It wasn't until I got involved in a couple of productions, and heard the lines spoken correctly, and saw how the director managed the scenes, that I began to enjoy Shakespeare.

Then I watched Kenneth Branagh's screen version of Henry V, and it blew my socks off. The lines flowed off his tongue so smoothly that I've been a fan ever since. Those British actors are tops when it comes to Shakespeare.

Monday, 04 January, 2010  
Blogger John Mutford said...

Christie: I'd have to agree-- I'm also in favour of his tragedies.

Steve: It was only after acting in MacBeth that I appreciated it. I had a high school teacher that just about ruined it for me way back in the day.

Monday, 04 January, 2010  

Saturday, January 02, 2010

Reader's Diary #559- Brian Selznick: The Invention of Hugo Cabret

I don't like to throw words like wonderful, amazing and marvelous around lightly.

Brian Selznick's The Invention of Hugo Cabret is wonderful. Winner of the Caldecott Medal in 2008, I wasn't sufficiently impressed at that point. I was almost guaranteed there'd be decent illustrations, but as it's an award for illustrations, I've learned that that doesn't always mean I'd like the book as a whole; sometimes the stories accompanying those Caldecott winners have been read duds. I've always felt that the relationship between text and illustrations needs more consideration.

The relationship between text and illustrations (and photographs) in Selznick's The Invention of Hugo Cabret is amazing. It's not that one simply enhances the other, it's that one is vital to the other. At 511 pages, it has gotten credit for being the first novel to win the Caldecott. But is it a novel? According to Selznick himself, "not exactly a novel, not quite a picture book, not really a graphic novel, or a flip book or a movie, but a combination of all these things." It's true, and it's that inventive approach to writing that makes this book so wildly exciting. It's a marvelous homage to imagination and wonder and, and, and... clearly I get giddy when talking about books this great.

Set in 1930s Paris, it is the tale of Hugo Cabret a twelve year old boy who lives and works at a train station. Hugo's life isn't easy but the hope of repairing a mysterious automaton (mechanical man) first discovered by Hugo's now deceased father keeps him going. But it's so much more than that. It's about time, clocks, magic and machinery. It's also a mystery and a tribute to the imaginative and innovative French director Georges Melies whose silent films of the turn of the century astounded audiences.

Even the production of the book itself is a treat. With its black framed pages, black and white movie stills, and sketches it captures the time brilliantly. Do modern readers need vibrantly coloured illustrations to hold their attention? My kids and I finished the book in two afternoons. Even if you don't have kids, you need to read this book.

A masterpiece.

Labels: , ,

Blogger raidergirl3 said...

Exactly.
It was like no other reading experience, and I want him to write another book.
So glad you all enjoyed it.

Saturday, 02 January, 2010  
Blogger John Mutford said...

Raidergirl's review here.

Saturday, 02 January, 2010  
Blogger Nicola said...

I felt the same way when I read it. It's like a whole new type of book that no one has a name for yet. I'm also hoping he writes another one.

Sunday, 03 January, 2010  
Blogger Nan said...

I adored this book, and wrote about it:

http://lettersfromahillfarm.blogspot.com/2009/08/invention-of-hugo-cabret-by-brian.html

(sorry, I haven't figured out the 'here' way of linking yet. someone tried to explain it but I didn't get it.)

Sunday, 03 January, 2010  
Blogger John Mutford said...

Nan: Thanks.

Nicola's review here.

Monday, 04 January, 2010  

Friday, January 01, 2010

The Canadian Book Challenge 3- 6th Roundup



Happy New Year!!!

Because I care, I'll not insert annoying noise maker sounds. But I do know how, and the thought had crossed my mind, so be good in 2010.

I hope you all had a wonderful New Year's Eve and have no headaches today and are looking forward to the next year, the next decade-- that last one was a bit of a roller coaster, don't you think?

In the meantime, I've rounded up all the books we've read so far and I'll edit today's post to add in your December reads. It is the halfway point, don't you know? It was quite interesting to compile. Looks like Margaret Atwood's Year of the Flood was quite the popular book last half. Other popular books include Linwood Barclay's Fear The Worst, and with authors such as Stephanie Meyers being quite well represented, I'd say genre fiction is alive and well in Canada. Plus, I'd say there's a quite healthy mix of contemporary and classic, well known and obscure. I'm also interested in seeing the number of people that reviewed the very same book. Check out those that you've read. Has someone else reviewed it? It could make for an interesting comparison. By the way, please check that your reviews are all there and the links are accurate. I've not spent a lot of time editing (it's the holidays, cut me some slack!) and I imagine the errors are rampant. There are somewhere between 250-300 book read and reviewed so far, but I can't get the numbers on the sidebar to match the numbers below (meaning I've screwed up somewhere-- help!!!)

I'll also congratulate Scrat, Raidergirl, Pooker, Nicola and myself for joining Kailana in reaching 13 books in December-- though I haven't quite reached my personal goal yet, which was to reach 13 books from each province or territory. My 13 so far includes the Yukon, the Northwest Territories, British Columbia, Alberta, Ontario and Newfoundland and Labrador. That leaves a whopping 7 to go-- ouch. But there's still time! I just need to choose more carefully.

Anyway, enjoy your day today. And please, since this is a roundup post, leave links to the books you'd read in December for the Canadian Book Challenge. Happy reading!!!

Adamson, Gil
- The Outlander (Kate, Kailana)
Akiwenzie-Damm, Kateri (Editor)
- Without Reservation (John)
Alexis, Andre
- Asylum (Scrat)
Allan, Von
- the road to god knows... (Nicola)
Anderson-Dargatz, Gail
- Turtle Valley (Tara, Scrat)
Armstrong, Kelley
- The Awakening (Becky, Kailana)
- Bitten (Nathan)
- Haunted (Kailana)
- Living With The Dead (Kailana)
- The Summoning (Linda)
Armstrong, Sally
- The Nine Lives of Charlotte Taylor (Raidergirl)
Atwood, Margaret
- Alias Grace (Eva)
- Bashful Bob and Doleful Dorinda illustrated by Dusan Petricic (Chris)
- The Handmaid's Tale (Lahni)
- Moral Disorder (Pooker)
- Oryx and Crake (Nicola)
- Year of the Flood (Corey, JK, Kate, Nicola, Lahni, Scrat, Chris, Charlotte, Kailana, Remi, Gavin, B. Kienapple)
Aubert, Rosemary
- The Ferryman Will Be There (Gypsysmom)
Babiak, Todd
- The Garneau Block (Lynn)
Barclay, Isabel
- O Canada (Nicola)
Barclay, Linwood
- Fear the Worst (Nicola, Luanne, Kerri, Teena)
- No Time For Goodbye (Raidergirl)
Bemrose, John
- The Last Woman (Pooker, Sandra)
Benham, Leslie and Lois
- The Heroine of Long Point illustrated by Vernon Mould (Nicola)
Bergen, David
- Sitting Opposite My Brother (Pooker)
Bezmozgis, David
- Natasha and Other Stories (Pooker)
Biscott, Lynn
- The Boomers Retire (Teena)
Blanchet, Pascal
- White Rapids (Gavin)
Blunt, Giles
- No Such Creature (Sandra)
Bowen, Gail
- Verdict in Blood (Gypsysmom)
Boyden, Joseph
- Through Black Spruce (Patricia, Kerri)
Bradley, Alan
- The Sweetness at the Bottom of the Pie (Nathan, Eva)
Brett, Brian
- Trauma Farm (Luanne)
Brown, Chester
- Louis Riel (Chris)
Brunt, Stephen
- Searching for Bobby Orr (Raidergirl)
Buchanan, Cathy Marie
- The Day the Falls Stood Still (Nicola, Kailana)
Burns, Cliff
- The Reality Machine (Corey)
Butala, Sharon
- Lunaby (Melanie)
- The Perfection of the Morning (B. Kienapple)
Capponi, Pat
- Last Stop Sunnyside (Lynn)
Carpenter, David
- Niceman Cometh (Melanie)
Chercover, Sean
- Trigger City (Teena)
Choy, Wayson
- All That Matters (Scrat)
- The Jade Peony (Scrat, Raidergirl)
- Not Yet (Ariel)
Clarke, George Elliot
- Whylah Falls (Steve)
Coady, Lynn
- Saints of Big Harbour (Steve)
Colapinto, John
- As Nature Made Him (Kailana)
Cole, Trevor
- Fearsome Particles (Tara)
Connolly, Karen
- The Lizard Cage (Raidergirl)
Cooper, Afua
- Hanging of Angelique (Charlotte)
Cohen, Bruce and Brian Fitzgerald
- The Pension Puzzle (Teena)
Coren, Stanley
- The Intelligence of Dogs (Jacki)
Coupland, Douglas
- Generation A (Corey, Remi)
- Souvenir of Canada (Raidergirl)
Craig, Alisa
- Murder Goes Mumming (Gypsysmom)
Crummey, Michael
- Galore (John, Luanne)
Crymble, Lynn
- It Can Happen to You (Luanne)
Davidge, Bud
- The Mummer's Song illustrated by Ian Wallace (Wanda)
Davidson, Andrew
- The Gargoyle (Scrat, Heather, Raidergirl)
Davies, Robertson
- Fifth Business (Raidergirl)
- Rebel Angels (Ariel, Steve)
- Tempest Tost (August)
Dawson, David Laing
- Don't Look Down (Heather)
Defeede, Jeff
- The Day The World Came to Town (Eva)
De La Roche, Mazo
- White Oaks of Jalna (Steve)
De Lint, Charles
- Forests of the Heart (Kailana)
- Memory and Dream (Eva)
- Wild Wood (Pussreboots)
Drummond, Robbie Newton
- Arctic Circle Songs (John)
Echlin, Kim
- The Disappeared (Kate)
Endicott, Marina
- Good to a Fault (Scrat, Raidergirl)
Evans, Polly
- Mad Dogs and an English Woman (Jacki)
Falcone, L.M.
- The Mysterious Mummer (John)
Ferguson, Will
- Beauty Tips from Moose Jaw (Kerri)
Finch, Robert
- The Iambics of Newfoundland (Kailana)
Findley, Timothy
- Not Wanted on the Voyage (Chris)
Fraser, Ivan
- Peggy of the Cove (Wanda)
Gabriele, Lisa
- Tempting Fate DiNapoli (Leya)
Galchen, Rivka
- Atmospheric Disturbances (B. Kienapple, Ariel)
Galloway, Stephen
- The Cellist of Sarajevo (Ariel)
Gibb, Camilla
- Sweetness in the Belly (Kailana)
Giles, W. Mark
- Knucklehead and Other Stories (Patricia)
Goldstein, Jonathan
- Ladies and Gentlemen The Bible! (Ariel)
Grant, Jessica
- Come, Thou Tortoise (Scrat)
Greenwood, Barbara
- A Pioneer Story (Nicola)
- A Pioneer Thanksgiving (Nicola)
- A Pioneer Christmas (Nicola)
Greer, Darren
- Still Life With June (B. Kienapple)
Grescoe, Taras
- The Devil's Picnic (Eva)
Gruen, Sara
- Water for Elephants (Patricia)
Gunn, Carla
- Amphibian (Corey)
Harvey, Kenneth J.
- Blackstrap Hawco (John)
Haworth-Attard, Barbara
- Haunted (Nicola)
Hay, Elizabeth
- Late Nights on Air (Geranium Cat, Wanda)
- A Student of Weather (Gavin)
Heidbreder, Robert
- Drumheller Dinosaur Dance illustrated by Bill Slavin and Esperanca Melo (John)
Helm, Michael
- In the Place of Last Things (Rosalynn)
Heti, Sheila
- Ticknor (Sandra)
Hicks, Faith Erin
- The War at Ellsmere (Nicola)
Highway, Tomson
- The Rez Sisters (Eva)
- Fox on the Ice (Teddy Rose)
- Dragonfly Kites (Teddy Rose)
- Caribou Song (Teddy Rose)
Hill, Lawrence
- The Book of Negroes (Lahni, Ariel, John, Eva)
Hitzer, Rolf
- Hoodoo Sea (Nicola, Gautami)
Humphreys, Helen
- the Lost Garden (Geranium Cat, Kailana)
Ilsley, George K
- ManBug (Corey)
Itani, Frances
- Leaning, Leaning Over Water (Pooker)
- Remembering the Bones (Nathan, Lesley, Raidergirl)
Jameson, Anna Brownell
- Winter Studies and Summer Ramblings (Susan)
Janes, Percy
- House of Hate (Steve)
Jarman, Mark Antony
- 19 Knives (Pooker)
Jarratt, Melynda
- War Brides (Kailana)
Jewison, Cathy
- The Ugly Truck and Dog Contest and Other Stories (John)
Johnson, P.J.
- Rhymes of the Raven Lady (John)
Johnston, Basil
- By Canoe & Moccasin (Heather)
- Crazy Dave (Heather)
Joyce, Ron
- Always Fresh (Teena)
Jumbo, Sheyenne and Mindy Willett
- Come and Learn With Me photograohy by Tessa Macintosh (John)
Kaslik, Ibi
- Skinny (Kerri)
Kaufman, Andrew
- All My Friends Are Superheroes (Remi)
Kennedy, Ellen
- Silent Watch (Linda)
Kidd, Monica
- Beatrice (Pooker)
King, Thomas
- Green Grass Running Water (Eva, Rosalynn)
Kirkby, Mary-Ann
- I Am Hutterite (Patricia)
Knowles, Mike
- Darwin's Nightmare (Corey)
Kogawa, Joy
- Obasan (Eva)
Kusugak, Michael
- The Littlest Sled Dog illustrated by Vladyana Krykorka (Debbie)
Lam, Vincent
- Bloodletting and Miraculous Cures (Barbara, Leya)
Lane, Dawn Beaumont
- Fairy Glade (Pussreboots)
Lane, Patrick
- Red Dog Red Dog (Ariel, Kerri)
Lansens, Lori
- The Wife's Tale (Nathan, Luanne)
Lau, Evelyn
- Runaway (Debbie)
Laurence, Margaret
- A Bird in the House (Gautami)
Lawson, Mary
- Crow Lake (Patricia)
Leacock, Stephen
- Sunshine Sketches of a Little Town (Steve)
Lee, Dennis
- Alligator Stew: Favourite Poems (Nicola)
Lemire, Jeff
- The Nobody (John)
- Tales from the Farm (John, Debbie, Wanda)
Lester, David
- The Gruesome Acts of Capitalism (Debbie)
London, Jack
- Call of the Wild (Jacki)
Ludwig, Sidura
- Holding My Breath (Melanie)
Lunn, Janet
- Larger Than Life (Nicola)
Lyon, Annabel
- The Golden Mean (Kate)
MacDonald, Ann-Marie
- Fall on Your Knees (Sandra)
MacGregor, Roy
- The Dog and I (Jacki)
MacIntyre, Linden
- The Bishop's Man (Raidergirl, Kate)
MacLean, Stuart
- Vinyl Cafe Diaries (Raidergirl)
MacLennan, Hugh
- The Watch That Ends The Night (Remi)
Macleod, Alison
- Wave Theory of Angels (Ariel)
Maffini, Mary Jane
- Death Loves a Messy Desk (Nathan)
Malone, Stephens Gerard
- I Still Have A Suitcase in Berlin (Wanda)
- Miss Elva (Scrat)
Mayor, Chandra
- Cherry (Pooker)
McAdam, Colin
- Fall (Kate)
McNaughton, Janet
- Dragon Seer (Heather)
Metcalf, John
- Shooting the Stars (Pooker)
Michaels, Anne
- the Winter Vault (Scrat, Kate)
Millar, Margaret
- How Like and Angel (Heather)
Mitchell, Shandi
- Under This Unbroken Sky (Melanie, B. Kienapple)
Mitchell, W.O.
- Jake and The Kid (Corey)
Montgomery, L. M.
- Kilmeny of the Orchard (Becky)
- The Blythes are Quoted (Charlotte)
Moore, Lisa
- February (Heather)
Morrissey, Donna
- What They Wanted (Barbara)
Morton, Alexandra
- In The Company of Whales (Gavin)
Moss, John
- Still Waters (Geranium Cat)
Mowat, Farley
- The Dog Who Wouldn't Be (Jacki, Geranium Cat)
- Grey Seas Under (Pussreboots)
- Never Cry Wolf (Geranium Cat)
Munday, Evan
- Quarter Life Crisis (B. Kienapple)
Munce, Alayna
- When I Was Young and In My Prime (Remi)
Munro, Alice
- Too Much Happiness (Kate, Rosalynn)
- The View from Castle Rock (Raidergirl, 3M)
Munsch, Robert
- From Far Away with Saoussan Askar and illustrated by Michael Martchenko (Teddy Rose)
- The Paperbag Princess illustrated by Michael Martchenko (Teddy Rose)
- Stephanie's Ponytail illustrated by Michael Martchenko (Teddy Rose)
- Where is Gah-Ning? illustrated by Helene Desputeaux (Teddy Rose)
Nadir, Leilah
- The Orange Trees of Baghdad (Kate)
Newfeld, Frank
- Drawing on Type (Charlotte)
Nielsen, Susin
- Word Nerd (JK)
North, Dick
- The Lost Patrol (John)
Novik, Mary
- Conceit (Sandra)
Obamsawim, Diane
- Kaspar (Chris)
Oppel, Kenneth
- Airborn (Lahni, Charlotte)
- Skybreaker (Lahni)
O'Reilly, Terry
- The Age of Persuasion (Barbara)
Patterson, Kevin
- Consumption (Wanda)
Pattison, Brad
- Synergy and Training Between Man and Dog (Jacki)
Pelley, Chad
- Away From Everywhere (Wanda)
Penny, Louise
- The Brutal Telling (Gautami)
- Still Life (Raidergirl, Gavin, Eva)
Phelan, Susan
- The Cure (Heather)
Poliquin, Daniel
- A Secret Between Us (Ariel)
Powning, Beth
- The Sea Captain's Wife (Scrat)
Preston, Allison
- Cherry Bites (Gypsysmom)
Pynn, Susan
- The Colours of My Home illustrated by Nancy Keating (Wanda)
Pyper, Andrew
- The Wildfire Season (Wanda)
Quarrington, Paul
- Galveston (Kerri)
Raddall, Thomas H.
- Halifax: Warden of the North (Steve)
- The Nymph and the Lamp (B. Kienapple)
Rayner, Mark A.
- Marvellous Hairy (Corey)
Redekop, Corey
- Shelf Monkey (Scrat)
Reichs, Kathy
- 206 Bones (Kate)
Remington, Robert and Sherri Zickefoose
- Runaway Devil (Debbie)
Ritter, Erika
- The Secret Life of Humans (Jacki)
Robinson, Peter
- The Price of Love and Other Stories (Luanne)
Rothman, Claire Holden
- The Heart Specialist (Ariel, Linda)
Salamon, Daria
- the Prairie Bridesmaid (Pooker)
Sandham, James
- The Entropy of Aaron Rosclatt (Sandra)
Schultz, Emily
- Heaven is Small (Heather)
Shatner, William
- Up Till Now (Nicola)
Shields, Carol
- Unless (3M)
Shrier, Howard
- Buffalo Jump (Teena)
- High Chicago (Teena)
Shubin, Neil
- Your Inner Fish (Pussreboots)
Simpson, Anne
- Falling (Raidergirl)
Slade, Arthur
- The Hunchback Assignments (Kailana, Nicola)
Smith, Russell
- Muriella Pent (Rosalynn)
Spires, Ashley
- Binky the Space Cat (Nicola)
Stegner, Wallace
- Wolf Willow (Pussreboots)
Steltzer, Ulli
- The Spirit of Haida Gwaii (John)
Stephens, Jay
- Monsters! Draw Your Own Mutants, Freaks & Creeps (Pussreboots)
Strube, Cordelia
- Lemon (B. Kienapple)
Tamaki, Mariko and Jillian
- Skim (Pussreboots, Eva)
Tardif, Cheryl Kaye
- The River (Gypsysmom)
Theis, Leona
- The Art of Salvage (Melanie)
Thomas, Joan
- Reading by Lightning (B. Kienapple, Pooker)
Toews, Miriam
- a complicated kindness (Kerri)
- The Flying Troutmans (Rosalynn, Scrat)
Tremblay, Michel
- The Fat Woman Next Door is Pregnant (Tanabata)
- Therese and Pierrette and the Little Hanging Angel (Charlotte)
Trofimuk, Thomas
- Waiting for Columbus (Luanne)
Turner, Max
- Night Runner (Becky)
Vanier, Jean
- Our Life Together (Kate)
Van Rooy, Michael
- An Ordinary Decent Criminal (Teena)
Vassanji, M.G.
- The Book of Secrets (Gavin)
Viswanathan, Padma
- The Toss of a Lemon (B. Kienapple)
Von Kampen, Bettina
- Blue Becomes You (Melanie)
Vreeland, Susan
- The Forest Lover (Eva)
Wake, Val
- White Bird Black Bird (John)
Wales, Dirk
- Jack London's Dog (John)
Wallace, Frederick William
- Blue Water (Steve)
Wasserman, Bryna
- The Naked Island (Scrat)
West, Michelle
- Hunter's Oath (Charlotte)
Whittal, Zoe
- Holding Still for as Long as Possible (B. Kienapple)
Willis, Deborah
- Vanishing & Other Stories (Pooker)
Windley, Carol
- Home Schooling (Pooker)
Winter, Michael
- All This Happened (Remi)
With, Cathleen
- Having Faith in the Polar Girls' Prison (John)
Wolfe, Inger Ash
- The Calling (Nicola)
- The Taken (Luanne, Nicola)
Wright, Richard B
- Clara Callan (Raidergirl)
Young, Terence
- Rhymes With Useless (Pooker)
Zelinski, Ernie J.
- How to Retire Happy, Wild and Free (Teena)
Zipp, Steve
- Yellowknife (Gavin, Kerri)

Labels: ,

Blogger John Mutford said...

My reviews for December include L.M. Falcone's The Mysterious Mummer, Ulli Steltzer's The Spirit of Haida Gwaii, Mindy Willett and Sheyenne Jumbo's Come and Learn With Me, Dick North's The Lost Patrol and Dirk Wales's Jack London's Dog which brings my total to 17.

Friday, 01 January, 2010  
OpenID charlotteashley said...

This month I reviewed (however briefly) Michelle West's Hunter's Oath, Kenneth Oppel's Airborn and Afua Cooper's Hanging of Angelique. I think that brings my total up to "not many". ;)

Friday, 01 January, 2010  
Blogger Kate said...

The month of December was busy for me, so I was wallowing in re-reads in the few precious minutes available to stick my nose in a book. Only one new book for me (and it was a Christmas present from my sister's mother-in-law):
The Blythes are Quoted by L. M. Montgomery

12 - I'm a Totem Pole!

Friday, 01 January, 2010  
Blogger Wanda said...

I spent the better part of December in Newfoundland, reading wise. Two more for me: The Mummer's Song ~ Bud Davidge and Away From Everywhere ~ Chad Pelley. This brings my total to 9.

Happy New Year!

Friday, 01 January, 2010  
Blogger Steve Zipp said...

Shitty.

That's my one-word verdict for book no. 8, The Rebel Angels by Robertson Davies.

But I mean that in the nicest possible way.

Friday, 01 January, 2010  
Blogger GeraniumCat said...

My reviews for December are Farley Mowat's Never Cry Wolf (I also reviewed The Dog Who Wouldn't Be a while ago, but didn't get round to saying so) and Still Waters by John Moss. I've still got my 6th book to review, so that takes me up to 5. I'm reading the 7th, so not too bad for the halfway mark! A Snowshoe - appropriate as I've just been for a walk in the snow.

Friday, 01 January, 2010  
Blogger Eva said...

I reviewed Someone Knows My Name by Lawrence Hill (aka Book of Negroes), which brings my total up to 12 and makes me a Totem Pole. I'm halfway through my 13th, so I plan to have finished the challenge by the end of this month! Me=excited.

Friday, 01 January, 2010  
Blogger Teena in Toronto said...

Such a great variety!

Happy new year!

Here are my December reads:

"Buffalo Jump" - Howard Shrier (www.teenaintoronto.com/2009/12/book-buffalo-jump-2008-howard-shrier.html)

"The Pension Puzzle" - Bruce Cohen and Brian Fitzgerald (www.teenaintoronto.com/2009/12/book-pension-puzzle-2007-bruce-cohen.html)

That makes 9 for me!

Friday, 01 January, 2010  
Blogger Scrat said...

I finished up two more Canadian novels this month: Turtle Valley by Gail Anderson-Dargatz as well as The Sea Captain's Wife by Beth Powning (a freebee from Librarything)which will be released this month. John, it is by a New Brunswick writer -- so maybe this could be one of your reads from that province.

Friday, 01 January, 2010  
Blogger Chris said...

I reviewed Kaspar by Diane Obomsawin:

http://chris-book-a-rama.blogspot.com/2009/12/kaspar-by-diane-obomsawin-review.html

That puts me at 5. I'm getting there!

Friday, 01 January, 2010  
Anonymous gypsysmom said...

I read one more Canadian mystery in December bringing my total to 5 for this challenge. It was The Ferryman will be There by Rosemary Aubert. This is the third in her series of Ellis Portal books about the judge who hit the skids and ended up living in the ravines of Toronto. Judge Portal is no longer homeless and he has a small fortune from his divorce settlement but he hasn't lost his affinity for the disadvantaged.

That's an amazing list of books and authors that you have compiled. Happy New Year to you.

Friday, 01 January, 2010  
Blogger Barbara Bruederlin said...

You are a reading MACHINE! Happy new year, John! One of my year's highlights was finally meeting you and your delightful family.

In December I reviewed The Age of Persuasion, bringing my total all the way up to three and making me a cowboy boot.

Friday, 01 January, 2010  
Blogger Allison said...

Wow. That's a lot of books. Well done, you!

Happy New Year! Methinks 2010 will be a good one.

Friday, 01 January, 2010  
Blogger pussreboots said...

I didn't read a single Canadian book in December. :(

Friday, 01 January, 2010  
Blogger Kerri said...

What a great list of books so far. Thanks for all the hard work, there are some good suggestions for 2010.

I finally got around to reading a complicated kindness by Miriam Toews.

This brings my total to 8.

Friday, 01 January, 2010  
Blogger Scrat said...

I guess with 14 Canuck novels read and reviewed I join the ranks of the Grain Elevators. What is the next level? CNTowers?

Friday, 01 January, 2010  
Blogger Gavin said...

Here is a link to In The Company of Whales by Alexandra Morton, a very interesting science book for middle grade readers. I believe that makes 6 books so far.

John, thanks for keeping track of all this and Happy 2010!

Friday, 01 January, 2010  
Blogger Luanne said...

Wow John - what a great compilation - thanks for all your hard work - it is great to see so many Canadian authors being read. I wish everyone health and happiness for 2010. I will remain on my little red river wagon for December as I read no Canadian books this month.... :(

Friday, 01 January, 2010  
Blogger Melanie said...

I reviewed only one this month, a slightly seasonal tale, David Carpenter's Niceman Cometh

That brings me up to 6 books, or Lobster Pot status... :)

Friday, 01 January, 2010  
OpenID mrspeachtree said...

That is a rather impressive list of books John! I'm rather sheepish when I admit that I haven't posted one review yet. I was aiming for another children's literature challenge and I chose to try and read the earliest Canadian children's literature. Unfortunately, a lot of my reading would have had to be done on a microfiche reader so I abandoned that idea. It was brought to my attention, however, that an area of children's literature that I am completely unfamiliar with is graphic novels. Sooo...I'm changing my goal to 13 Canadian graphic novels for children/teens and I'll just have to do two reviews per month to catch up!

Friday, 01 January, 2010  
Blogger raidergirl3 said...

I finished in December!
I read:

The Nine Lives of Charlotte Taylor by Sally Armstrong, http://raidergirl3-anadventureinreading.blogspot.com/2009/12/book-nine-lives-of-charlotte-taylor-by.html

Vinyl Cafe Diaries by Stuart MacLean, http://raidergirl3-anadventureinreading.blogspot.com/2009/12/book-vinyl-cafe-diaries-by-stuart.html

Good to a Fault by Marina Endicott, http://raidergirl3-anadventureinreading.blogspot.com/2009/12/list-canada-reads-2010.html

and I just finished The Jade Peony by Wayson Choy, http://raidergirl3-anadventureinreading.blogspot.com/2009/12/list-canada-reads-2010.html

Friday, 01 January, 2010  
Blogger Jacki said...

I remain a snowmobile. I only read two books in December, and neither was Canadian. However, I did stockpile 3 books for my theme from birthday/Christmas gifts, so will hopefully motor along in January. Not sure if I should check out Jack London's Dog or not, based on John's review :-S Fits my theme, but .... we'll see I guess.

Happy New Year all!

And, btw, all 7 books I read/reviewed thus far are in John's masterlist.

Friday, 01 January, 2010  
Blogger Nicola said...

What an awesome list!

I only added two more reviews this month making my total books read up to 20.

the road to god knows ... by Von Allen

A Pioneer Chritmas by Barbara Greenwood

Friday, 01 January, 2010  
Blogger Teddy Rose said...

I didn`t read any in December. Congrats to everyone who finished the challenge! What a great list we all have going here!

Saturday, 02 January, 2010  
Anonymous Pooker said...

Oh the shame of it all. I've done lots of reading, but zilch for reviewing. So nothing more to add this month.

I see a few on the list that I have waiting on Mount TBR, so I'll be reading those for inspiration. Happy New Year!

Saturday, 02 January, 2010  
Blogger Sandra said...

Lots of reading done here but not much reviewing.

#2. Conceit***** by Mary Novik - best thing I've read in a while. Reviewed here:

http://freshinkbooks.blogspot.com/2009/08/show-me-5-saturday.html

Also read:

#3.The Entropy of Aaron***+ Rosclatt by James Sandham
#4.The Last Woman**** by John Bemrose
#5.Ticknor***+ by Sheila Heti
#6. Fall On Your Knees****+ by Anne-Marie McDonald -loved it.

I must read through your list for some good recommendations. Hope to read the other four entries in Canada Reads too. Take care.

Saturday, 02 January, 2010  
Blogger Remi said...

I'm a little late but in December I reviewed Alayna Munce's When I Was Young and In My Prime. I also read Andrew Kaufman's All My Friends Are Superheroes but I didn't review it until today. That brings me up to seven books.

Monday, 04 January, 2010  
Blogger Heather said...

sorry to be so slow. I had 2 reads for December which brings me to a total of 9.

Crazy Dave by Basil Johnston

By Canoe & Moccasin: Some Native Place Names of the Great Lakes by Basil H. Johnston

Wednesday, 06 January, 2010  
Blogger B.Kienapple said...

Batting 0 for December 09. Agh. So I'm still sitting at 11. I am so impressed by this list that you compiled, John (and how many Canadian books were read!)

Thursday, 07 January, 2010